IMHO I think if you want a decent car with a bit of poke and a awesome sound but arnt to bothered about modifying get te v6 4motion
If you want something that you plan on modifying to 250bhp+ get the 1.8t
And if you want to be seen as If your doing 2mph (or atuck in the garagebroken down) as the guys in the v6 and 1.8t fly past then get a 2.0L
