GolfGTIforum.co.uk

Model specific boards => Golf mk6 => Topic started by: MAW73 on 11 August 2010, 11:14

Title: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: MAW73 on 11 August 2010, 11:14
Does anyone with a DSG actually ever use the paddleshifts regularly? In thinking I was the next ‘Lewis Hamilton’, I had a little play with the paddleshifts this morning on the way in to work. Good fun, but to be honest it’s the first time I've ever really used them.




 
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: PenguinGTI on 11 August 2010, 11:16
I use them every day that I drive my car. I couldn't have an automatic without them. I also use the shifter mode on the stick alot.
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: MikeT on 11 August 2010, 11:27
I use them more than I use auto really.

I only really use full auto when I'm in traffic.
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: mike. on 11 August 2010, 11:37
Use them all the time as well, don't really like the auto modes, except when stuck in traffic.

I used them that much on the MK5 that I had to get one replaced under warranty as the rubber coating had worn off  :laugh:
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: MAW73 on 11 August 2010, 11:57
^^^ Cheers for the replies.... that's interesting as I've never really used them. Well I don't want to miss out on the action, so I best give them a real go.

Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: avalon on 11 August 2010, 12:22
It took me a couple of weeks to start using the paddles and the gearshift but I must admit I haven't really used them in anger yet - most of my 800 miles have been in traffic.

I am though heading to the North Yorks Moors next week for a few days so should get a good opportunity to use them there.



Ava
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: Steve30 on 11 August 2010, 12:31
Use mine everyday best feature of the car!! :smug:
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: FroGTI on 11 August 2010, 13:31
Every time I use them, I say to myself that I should really use them a lot more often. But I don't :rolleyes:
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: MAW73 on 11 August 2010, 14:40
I have to confess on my last car (a MK5 GT 170 DSG) I honestly didn't use the paddleshifts once in nearly 3 years of owning the car. What a lazy driver I must be :embarassed:

I shall endeavour to make amends on the GTI and see what I'm missing  :wink:






Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: gizzywizzy on 11 August 2010, 15:57
It took me a couple of weeks to start using the paddles and the gearshift but I must admit I haven't really used them in anger yet - most of my 800 miles have been in traffic.

I am though heading to the North Yorks Moors next week for a few days so should get a good opportunity to use them there.



Ava

Oh yeah where abouts?


The road from Pickering to Whitby across the Moors is an ideal run for the GTI with plenty of straights and some tricky bends too.
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: FroGTI on 11 August 2010, 17:34
The road from Pickering to Whitby across the Moors is an ideal run for the GTI with plenty of straights and some tricky bends too.

+1. I used to love that road when I lived in Yorkshire. Haven't been back in a long while, though. I'd love to give it a go in the GTI :cool:
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: Saint Steve on 11 August 2010, 18:11
Does anyone with a DSG actually ever use the paddleshifts regularly? In thinking I was the next ‘Lewis Hamilton’, I had a little play with the paddleshifts this morning on the way in to work. Good fun, but to be honest it’s the first time I've ever really used them.




 

Always in manual, always use my extended Carbon fibre paddleshifters
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: am1w on 11 August 2010, 18:14
Does anyone with a DSG actually ever use the paddleshifts regularly? In thinking I was the next ‘Lewis Hamilton’, I had a little play with the paddleshifts this morning on the way in to work. Good fun, but to be honest it’s the first time I've ever really used them.
Always in manual, always use my extended Carbon fibre paddleshifters

How very strange paddling on tarmac. :evil: :grin:
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: gizzywizzy on 11 August 2010, 18:41
The road from Pickering to Whitby across the Moors is an ideal run for the GTI with plenty of straights and some tricky bends too.

+1. I used to love that road when I lived in Yorkshire. Haven't been back in a long while, though. I'd love to give it a go in the GTI :cool:

I love it in my standard manual GTI, so for a remapped car using the paddles = awesome :wink:
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: am1w on 11 August 2010, 18:48
The road from Pickering to Whitby across the Moors is an ideal run for the GTI with plenty of straights and some tricky bends too.
+1. I used to love that road when I lived in Yorkshire. Haven't been back in a long while, though. I'd love to give it a go in the GTI :cool:
I love it in my standard manual GTI, so for a remapped car using the paddles = awesome :wink:

Eh? You've lost me well and truly. Explain yourself right now. :grin:

PS: Got it. DOH. I thought you liked paddling inside your GTi!
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: GolfTi on 11 August 2010, 19:31
Mine's a manual as I dislike automatics.

If I had one though I'd probably use the paddles and gear lever shift a lot for the first 6 months or so.


Then leave it in auto.


Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: gizzywizzy on 11 August 2010, 22:27
The road from Pickering to Whitby across the Moors is an ideal run for the GTI with plenty of straights and some tricky bends too.
+1. I used to love that road when I lived in Yorkshire. Haven't been back in a long while, though. I'd love to give it a go in the GTI :cool:
I love it in my standard manual GTI, so for a remapped car using the paddles = awesome :wink:

Eh? You've lost me well and truly. Explain yourself right now. :grin:

PS: Got it. DOH. I thought you liked paddling inside your GTi!

No paddling for me, I like to use my left hand to play with my stick :evil: What do you do with yours? answers on a postcard to....... :grin:
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: am1w on 11 August 2010, 22:48
No paddling for me, I like to use my left hand to play with my stick :evil: What do you do with yours? answers on a postcard to....... :grin:

Do you use your stick to control the dogs whilst they are rounding the sheep? :tongue:
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: MAW73 on 12 August 2010, 10:40
Does anyone with a DSG actually ever use the paddleshifts regularly? In thinking I was the next ‘Lewis Hamilton’, I had a little play with the paddleshifts this morning on the way in to work. Good fun, but to be honest it’s the first time I've ever really used them.




 

Always in manual, always use my extended Carbon fibre paddleshifters

Saint Steve, I'm liking the sound of 'extended carbon fibre paddleshifters'...... more information required please!
Thanks MAW73
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: Davstylee on 12 August 2010, 12:11
Use them all the time as well, don't really like the auto modes, except when stuck in traffic.

I used them that much on the MK5 that I had to get one replaced under warranty as the rubber coating had worn off  :laugh:

I have a MK5 GTI that is nearly 5 years old now, and the rubber coating on my paddle sifts has started to wear off. I brought the car from a main dealer in November and it came with the extended warranty, do you think they will replace mine under the warranty?
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: MAW73 on 12 August 2010, 12:20
Use them all the time as well, don't really like the auto modes, except when stuck in traffic.

I used them that much on the MK5 that I had to get one replaced under warranty as the rubber coating had worn off  :laugh:

I have a MK5 GTI that is nearly 5 years old now, and the rubber coating on my paddle sh!ts has started to wear off. I brought the car from a main dealer in November and it came with the extended warranty, do you think they will replace mine under the warranty?

Its certainly worth a try, good luck with it!
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: Saint Steve on 12 August 2010, 20:47
Does anyone with a DSG actually ever use the paddleshifts regularly? In thinking I was the next ‘Lewis Hamilton’, I had a little play with the paddleshifts this morning on the way in to work. Good fun, but to be honest it’s the first time I've ever really used them.
 

Always in manual, always use my extended Carbon fibre paddleshifters

Saint Steve, I'm liking the sound of 'extended carbon fibre paddleshifters'...... more information required please!
Thanks MAW73

TID styling paddles, simply adhere to the back of the exsisting paddle. Not cheap, but were £160 when i brought mine, now about more now!! :shocked:

http://www.ttshop.co.uk/interior.asp?cat=5002&product=202604
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: jonnygo on 12 August 2010, 21:09
It took me a while to adjust to DSG.  I mean 20 yrs driving manuals and its going to be strange dropping gears without lifting your foot off the accelerator then slowly depressing a clutch

I am still adjusting but have found that the real beauty of DSG is its ability to work as a hybrid of automatic and manual.

I live and work in London so Automatic saves me from constantly putting it into first, second then back again.

When I leave work and take on less traffic its time for fun with the paddles.  Whats really clever is that even if you leave the stick in manual the car will still change down the gears if you stop using the paddles for a bit.

Its the best of both worlds in my opinion.  Only downside is there is a certain jerkiness to DSG opposed to a manual but then I reckon its just me getting used to it.
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: MAW73 on 12 August 2010, 21:27
Does anyone with a DSG actually ever use the paddleshifts regularly? In thinking I was the next ‘Lewis Hamilton’, I had a little play with the paddleshifts this morning on the way in to work. Good fun, but to be honest it’s the first time I've ever really used them.
 

Always in manual, always use my extended Carbon fibre paddleshifters

Saint Steve, I'm liking the sound of 'extended carbon fibre paddleshifters'...... more information required please!
Thanks MAW73

TID styling paddles, simply adhere to the back of the exsisting paddle. Not cheap, but were £160 when i brought mine, now about more now!! :shocked:

http://www.ttshop.co.uk/interior.asp?cat=5002&product=202604

Very nice, they really look the buisness. Blimey there not cheap though.  :shocked: I may have to raid my sons piggy bank for those  :grin:

 
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: Saint Steve on 12 August 2010, 21:44
Does anyone with a DSG actually ever use the paddleshifts regularly? In thinking I was the next ‘Lewis Hamilton’, I had a little play with the paddleshifts this morning on the way in to work. Good fun, but to be honest it’s the first time I've ever really used them.
 

Always in manual, always use my extended Carbon fibre paddleshifters

Saint Steve, I'm liking the sound of 'extended carbon fibre paddleshifters'...... more information required please!
Thanks MAW73

TID styling paddles, simply adhere to the back of the exsisting paddle. Not cheap, but were £160 when i brought mine, now about more now!! :shocked:

http://www.ttshop.co.uk/interior.asp?cat=5002&product=202604

Very nice, they really look the buisness. Blimey there not cheap though.  :shocked: I may have to raid my sons piggy bank for those  :grin:

 

They are an absolute must imo, and so easy to stick on.You can change gear with your hands higher up the wheel rather then fighting with the tiny oem paddles which are frankly too short.
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: SteveP on 12 August 2010, 22:15
I tried the TID paddles and was massively disappointed as the stick on nature meant they didn't react as well as the original ones in IHMO, so swapped to the OSIR GT Shift ali paddles.

As seen below on my Mk5, now on my Mk6  :cool:

(http://i281.photobucket.com/albums/kk207/Stevep_010/IMG_2732.jpg)

(http://i281.photobucket.com/albums/kk207/Stevep_010/IMG_2733.jpg)

I would 100% recommend these but be aware the airbag needs to be removed for fitting.
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: Rolfe on 12 August 2010, 22:48
I haven't used the paddles much, really.  It's a familiarity thing, I think.  To me, changing gear means a clutch and a gear-stick, and I'm not used to the idea of just pressing a button.

Still.  I've been taking a narrow, winding country road to avoid road works this week.  The DSG isn't completely satisfactory on that.  I tried putting it in S instead of D, but that wasn't what I wanted either.  This morning, after reading this thread last night, I put it in manual and used the paddles.  That did it.  Held the gear I knew it should be in (because I can see what's ahead and the DSG box can't), and I didn't even need to take my hands off the wheel.

I need to remember about the stick-shift capability for when the paddles are out of reach.  Again it's practice - so much of the time it's just fine leaving it in D, so extended practice doesn't tend to happen.

I still find it slightly jerky compared to a manual with the possibility of slipping the clutch, but it's not a problem - I'm capable of being just as jerky with a manual if I'm not paying 100% attention.  The advantages massively outweight the advantages.

I think the DSG is the future, really.  When young drivers start to learn on them, and don't get used to a manual clutch, there won't even be an argument.

Rolfe.
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: Saint Steve on 13 August 2010, 09:29
I tried the TID paddles and was massively disappointed as the stick on nature meant they didn't react as well as the original ones in IHMO, so swapped to the OSIR GT Shift ali paddles.



TID ones on my Ed30.

No issues with slow shift, Redrobin and Hurdy have these same set and their opinions are the same as mine.

(http://i154.photobucket.com/albums/s264/philmcavity/TIDPaddles001.jpg)
More expensive but worth it imo.
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: MikeT on 15 August 2010, 20:13
I tried the TID paddles and was massively disappointed as the stick on nature meant they didn't react as well as the original ones in IHMO, so swapped to the OSIR GT Shift ali paddles.



TID ones on my Ed30.

No issues with slow shift, Redrobin and Hurdy have these same set and their opinions are the same as mine.

(http://i154.photobucket.com/albums/s264/philmcavity/TIDPaddles001.jpg)
More expensive by worth it.

Got any more pics? I think I might have to get a set...
Title: Re: DSG Paddleshift's, ever use them?
Post by: Saint Steve on 15 August 2010, 21:02
http://www.tidstyling.com/shop/step1.php?number=601


another link to TID styling  :smiley: