Im not saying dont do it, it does look ok but imho the red stripe is one of the details that makes it recognizable as a GTI as well as the monza's and the red is
....I couldn't agree more. Each to their own, BUT!! the Red Stripe is one of the GTI features which pays homage to the long and successful history of this iconic car. To me, it's sacrilege to change it. It's the sort of thing which most Americans don't begin to understand. But, it's your car and you should do absolutely what gives you pleasure
I spotted a black GTI the other day with the red stripe painted white. It looked really clean cut, but not very aggressive. That said, his interior was a black-white motif as well, so it all matched up and looked good overall.