Don't get on the SSG route, you end up looking like the parcel shelf nodding dog with one of those, hence why the new M3 2 pedal will be a DSG type copy twin clutch affair

, must have been a lot of Germanic corporate pride swallowed on that one, bet they are p*ssing their pants in Wolfsburg at the Munchen boys climbdown
The S option is OK, but you are still leaving control to the computer, and thats not what I am looking for, but it is down to personal preferences.
Also, Mike, well impressed that you are such an animal lover, you bought your dog a GTI, top man