oright folks. new to the forum so be gentle.
i got a 97 mrk3 8v gti 62k and like much of the ^^^^^ i got a rattle from the front heat shield. i've been back to the garage at no cost to get it fixed and the dude has now welded it on 3 occasions. just been on a round trip of 400 miles and i can here the rattle coming back in at between 2 1/2 and 3 grand on the rev counter.
he said that to fix the problem if it still continues would be to buy a brand new section at 150+vat or to take it out and sort it as the current part is in good nik apart from the rattle. he was saying it's a c**t to get to so maybe taking it out to sort it would be better?
i am sure he said he used a jubilee clip in there last time i was in(last friday). is there another way to sort this

as i don't want to pay out the 150 quid for a new part if he can't fix it once its out.....
cheers in advance
actionslax