I remember reading that thread and saying to myself "bet his fans are blaring full speed with that unplugged" which you confirmed a few lines later

with the mk7's now coming out of their warranty period more and more of them are ending up at independant garages so i'm sure i've plenty more head scratching ahead of me, luckily ODIS is pretty good at highlighting root causes where other scan tools can send you off on wild goose chases. That being said vcds is still my "go-to" tool.