I also have the dtuk box on my car. I was considering getting a revo map, as I had one on my ibiza cupra and it was excellent. In the interests of warranty however, I decided upon the box. The choice was between either a JB4 or a DtUK one. I decided upon the latter as the JB4 required a wire through the firewall.
I found the staff very helpful and had the box delievered within a couple of days. It came well packaged and the instructions were also clear. I installed it within half an hour, as only the lower boost sensor was hard to reach ( I removed the lower underbody cover.) Upon speaking with Andrew, he advised to try each setting and then settle upon the one which suited best.
After playing with it over the course of the weekend, I have settled upon map 2, boost +1, which I find perfect. As said, the power comes in slightly highter in the rev range, but in a smooth fashion. I have heard of people having over boost issues and check lights, but this has never happened to myself.
With regards to comparison with a map, I can see pros and cons to both. A revo one obviously takes account of more variables than the box, which deals with two boost sensors and the camshaft position sensor. Whilst I imagine this will allow for more precise regulation of timing advance and fuelling etc, I can honestly say that when driving with the box, it does not feel at all lumpy; it feels well judged and refined. I also like the fact that you can change map to suit your preferences.
I have a few other minor mods such as the racingline turbo elbow and the gfb dverter valve. The box has worked very well in conjuction with these and caused no issues. I imagine that if you had the like of a sports cat/decat, you would need either a bespoke map, or a stage two revo one for example. If someone was able to drive a well mapped car and one with a box back to back, then maybe a difference between the two would be apparent. If however you are driving in isolation, and want a noticeable increase in power, then I have nothing negative to say about DTUK.
Thanks, Craig