Greencode, when you question whether a GTi or an R is better for your money?
I think that is down to you, coming from a Type R you may like the Fwd PP with the Vaq electronic diff, or feel like a change for a 4wd.
I have owned and driven fast compact 4wd cars and for me it all becomes a bit one dimensional. I also prefer the aesthetics of the GTi.
Personally I am not about to move to an R.
Others will have the opposite view which is good, the point being buy what you prefer rather than what you perceive as better for your money.