............... I can't think of anything other than a Golf - but that would be a little sad to have two cars the same 
Sad in who's eyes? Yours or your neighbours?

When we set out to get my Mrs a new car she had loads of suggestions. We'd be out together and she'd be like "Oh I like that car", "and I like that one"
As I've said before she only had a couple of stipulations so after looking at various cars I was always drawn back to the Golf as it had so much standard kit. Other cars might have had the keyless and heated seats that she wanted but literally nothing else for not far off what we would be paying for a Golf so the Golf won.
Albeit its 2 different versions of the golf we have in the GTD & GTI but the neighbours don't see it like that as they say "I see you got yourself another Golf"

but it matters not a jot to me.
Get what "you" want.
In fact since getting the other Golf I've noticed there is quite a lot of duplication. In our street alone in the same households there are 2 Jeep, A4's, Focus's, 3 series and minis
