I'm not sure there is a consensus, in that premium brand tyres are good enough for most of us?
From recent tests the best of the current crop are Continental sport contact 7, Michelin PS5 & Goodyear Eagle F1 assymetric 6.
I needed a pair, I went with the Goodyear as they were available at the best price on a black Friday deal.
Slightly controvesially, I went with 235/35/19 on my Brescia rims, partly for better rim protection and also 235/35/19 appear to be cheaper and more available than 225/35/19 original fitment.
Having driven 100 miles or less on them, I am unable to comment on how they drive, but the VW garage was happy when it passed it's Mot.