if you like them then that's all that matters.
This is true, but not really an opinion on how they would look on a Mk2...
I like those older wheels on a Mk1 or a mk2 Scirocco, but feel they would be a sideways step on a Mk2 Golf.
Could be made to look nice by painting a darker silver, and polishing the lip to a mirror finish
I still think a set of mint G60 steelies take a lot of beating on a Mk2, for a timeless look
JMO
Thom