Since when have BMW stamped their wheels with a VW? 
OOppps, missed the vw stamp.

Yes bm wheels are 24 offset, whats vw 40 something?
Sorry op ignore my over excited ramblings.

[/quote]

I don't think the BMW ones are identical, very similar but the part where the spokes cross is thicker on the vw ones which seems to give a more curved look.