Well im crazy then,
Me too.
No doubt the R is faster. And more surefooted.
I don't like it to look at as much as the GTI or the interior - both subjective, of course.
Whilst the extra power and bigger turbo would be nice...I just find it a bit dull to drive...similar to the S3 really...efficient, quick...but far duller than the GTI.
The fact that the GTI doesn't just grip and go, probably makes it the more entertaining in my mind.
And at £36-37k for the spec of R I would have wanted...it wasn't worth the extra cash.
Lovely cars...just not for me.