if i had the money 'coil overs' would be the set up for me, yeah the ride may be harsh, but if you choose and expensive option then you have damper adjustment aswell as height adjustment etc.
Im not knocking anyone here, but if you buy coilovers and dont know how to set them up correctly it may well have you thinking what you have spent your money on!!!(not that i know how to set them up, but if your investing in some quality kit then surely it pays to invest in having them set up properly and to be told how they work and how to set them rather than 'yeah you can get it on the deck with them on' then your unhappy with the set up.....
i havent had any coilovers on any of my cars as they are out of my price range on either of my cars. On my 8v k jet i had last year it had a brand new 'spax' springs and short damper set up, and it did handle really well, then on the other 8v i had i think it had a 'g-max' strut/spring set up which had a good ride etc but didnt feel as 'tidy' as the early one (maybe power steering took that away???) dunno what set up the 16v is running but its ok, on my mk4 im running standard struts/dampers and ive noticed (the few times i get to drive it) the back end has sarted to feel bouncey since i put the 40mm drop springs on in june last year!!
I spose its all down to money/taste/and what your doing with the car, so if its gonna be a 'road legal track car' id plump for the coilovers and get them set up properly and learn how to adjust yourself, i think then youll be smilling through every 'b' road twist/bend you ever take!!
just my bit!!
Gaz
