The Scirrocco R same spec ( and better looking ) is 5K cheaper!!
I agreee, also the Scirocco weighs 100kg less than the Golf. The Golf may be quicker off the line due to the better traction, but once rolling I think the Scirocco will be slightly quicker.
3dr Golf - 1521kg - 180bhp/ton
Scirocco - 1419kg - 189bhp/ton
Better looking, maybe slightly quicker, cheaper and better specced as standard. Both great cars but I think I'd take the Scirocco.