The little extra torque in the 16v is cancelled out by its extra weight, thats why 8v seems punchier low down.........I've had 2 16v before my current 8v, 8v is much more flexible low down in everyday use regardless of torque figures and the 8v digi is more tolerant of lower octane fuels. Mind you 16v goes like stink when you get past 4500rpm, if you don't mind living up there its great. Bodywork condition is really the most important issue with these now, make sure you drive any car from stone cold to check for second gear 'crunch' as well.