oh come on, does it really matter who's faster? If so go down to the pod and have a race. I like my mk5 because it is comfortable and has many creature comforts that the Mk2 simply doesn't have. The Mk2 on the other hand does have character and charm which newer cars do not. Swings and roundabouts, methinks.
On a side not, I did see in Next a Golf GTI Haynes T-shirt with a Mk2 on it, I think. I was distracted by the Mr T and Popeye t-shirts on the next rack.