GolfGTIforum.co.uk
Model specific boards => Golf mk7 => Topic started by: cyclopops on 28 September 2017, 07:45
-
Tyres, which and why?
I need new tyres, it's going to be either Goodyear eagle AS3 £90, Michelin PS4 £112 or continental premium contract 6 £102
Which would you buy?
-
My pal has his own tyre garage and i aksed him this last week he compared the hankook evo2 to the goodyears and said id be better with hankooks as cheaper and do the same job as the eagles saved about £45 as needed 2 tyres
-
And i had contis on my mini and didnt rate them at all
-
Did you have the Continental 6s on your mini Jeni? If not then can't really compare. General consensus on here is go for the Michelins if you want the best tyres with an alternative of the Conti 6s.
-
PS4's for best balance of grip vs wear life vs noise and Conti 6's for best grip with the downside of probably wearing out 20-30% quicker.
I had Eagle AS's on my last GTD. They were OK, noticeably better than the OEM BS's for sure. Not as good as the PS's I finally got though.
My new GTD is my own, so my own tyre choice. Its going to be PS4's.
-
Conti 5Ps are great tyres. Served me very well on GTI's and R over last 5 years. Michelin PS4S are better - on another level and worth it for the rescued noise and superlative pothole absorbing qualities alone, never mind the astonishing level of grip in wet and dry. Have actually transformed my daily commute.
-
Did you have the Continental 6s on your mini Jeni? If not then can't really compare. General consensus on here is go for the Michelins if you want the best tyres with an alternative of the Conti 6s.
I did ask this very question last week and nobody really responded hence me going with the Hankooks i was limited in choice as AC were paying for 1 of them so wasnt given an option about £80
-
Conti 5Ps are great tyres. Served me very well on GTI's and R over last 5 years. Michelin PS4S are better - on another level and worth it for the rescued noise and superlative pothole absorbing qualities alone, never mind the astonishing level of grip in wet and dry. Have actually transformed my daily commute.
Luckily motor came with 5Ps and although feel fine they are on the noisy side but for sure will go the PS4S route when requires. Always loved Michies, were the only real choice years back, fantastic on the Clio Williams.
Out of interest, any R owners bother with winter tyres these days, recall some did on the Mk6 mainly North of the border though.
-
Did you have the Continental 6s on your mini Jeni? If not then can't really compare. General consensus on here is go for the Michelins if you want the best tyres with an alternative of the Conti 6s.
I did ask this very question last week and nobody really responded hence me going with the Hankooks i was limited in choice as AC were paying for 1 of them so wasnt given an option about £80
Can't say i saw it Jeni, I'd have given you the answer if I had...
Not that I'd imagine the Shark would splash out for premium rubber...
-
Tyres, which and why?
I need new tyres, it's going to be either Goodyear eagle AS3 £90, Michelin PS4 £112 or continental premium contract 6 £102
Which would you buy?
The PS4 just won 2017 evo tyre test and their test car was a Mk7.5 Golf GTI.
-
The results of the Auto Motor und Sport 2017 "Summer tyre test":
http://www.tyrereviews.co.uk/Article/2017-AMS-Summer-Tyre-Test.htm
-
Conti 5Ps are great tyres. Served me very well on GTI's and R over last 5 years. Michelin PS4S are better - on another level and worth it for the rescued noise and superlative pothole absorbing qualities alone, never mind the astonishing level of grip in wet and dry. Have actually transformed my daily commute.
Luckily motor came with 5Ps and although feel fine they are on the noisy side but for sure will go the PS4S route when requires. Always loved Michies, were the only real choice years back, fantastic on the Clio Williams.
Out of interest, any R owners bother with winter tyres these days, recall some did on the Mk6 mainly North of the border though.
Yes many R owners bother with winter tyres and winter wheels too, you'll find it's a topic of seasonal discussion on the R forum if you ever pop your head in there. :smiley:
-
Just put 4 x PS4 on my Golf PP and they are spot on and really good in the wet as well and also had them on my E90 330d sport I had previously so a thumbs up from me but I don't think you will really go far wrong with any of the top sport brands for 99% of drivers and a golf GTI will never be whisper quiet .
-
Ordered 2 mchellins ps4 for fitting tomorrow.
-
Come back and tell us what you think when you have them
-
Conti 5Ps are great tyres. Served me very well on GTI's and R over last 5 years. Michelin PS4S are better - on another level and worth it for the rescued noise and superlative pothole absorbing qualities alone, never mind the astonishing level of grip in wet and dry. Have actually transformed my daily commute.
Not the same car, but I found the Contis good when new but went a bit ordinary fairly quickly. Life was ok overall, but if a fair proportion of that was :huh:, possibly not that great. I did buy quite a few of them as well, in various iterations (bar the very latest - 6?). As in a lot of them!
However, still probably better than the Bridgestones, so looking forward to them giving up :smiley:. Which might take forever :angry:.
-
Another Michelin PS4 fan.
Had them for six months with about 7,000 miles on them now.
Great tyre - good grip in wet & dry plus low noise.
Previously preferred Conti but swayed by good reviews to try these.
-
Conti 5Ps are great tyres. Served me very well on GTI's and R over last 5 years. Michelin PS4S are better - on another level and worth it for the rescued noise and superlative pothole absorbing qualities alone, never mind the astonishing level of grip in wet and dry. Have actually transformed my daily commute.
Not the same car, but I found the Contis good when new but went a bit ordinary fairly quickly. Life was ok overall, but if a fair proportion of that was :huh:, possibly not that great. I did buy quite a few of them as well, in various iterations (bar the very latest - 6?). As in a lot of them!
However, still probably better than the Bridgestones, so looking forward to them giving up :smiley:. Which might take forever :angry:.
See I found Conti 5Ps good throughout their lifespan, they never missed a beat. Got 12k miles out of each set of fronts on my GTI, and 14k out of them on the R with still between 3-4" tread, so tyres fare better on the R in terms of longevity. The only downsides to 5Ps for me are noise and a bit hard ride on 19s. The PS4S are much much quieter and a more comfortable ride. Best of both worlds as DCC always either in Sport or Normal (don't like Comfort - too wallowy) and the Michelins take care of the comfort side of things without the wallowing.
-
Got the PS4 fit and tread depth is only 7.1mm that's not right surely?
-
"7.2mm tread depth, as opposed to the 8mm once seen from new on sport tyres."
So yes, thats correct.
You'd imagine this would compromise the wet braking, but it doesn't...
Clever those Frenchies eh?
In (top end) motorsport you now can get wet slicks...
-
Conti 5Ps are great tyres. Served me very well on GTI's and R over last 5 years. Michelin PS4S are better - on another level and worth it for the rescued noise and superlative pothole absorbing qualities alone, never mind the astonishing level of grip in wet and dry. Have actually transformed my daily commute.
Luckily motor came with 5Ps and although feel fine they are on the noisy side but for sure will go the PS4S route when requires. Always loved Michies, were the only real choice years back, fantastic on the Clio Williams.
Out of interest, any R owners bother with winter tyres these days, recall some did on the Mk6 mainly North of the border though.
Yes many R owners bother with winter tyres and winter wheels too, you'll find it's a topic of seasonal discussion on the R forum if you ever pop your head in there. :smiley:
I've found winter tyres a must on my GTI.
-
Got the PS4 fit and tread depth is only 7.1mm that's not right surely?
My PS4's were 8mm new.
Made in Spanish plant 50/16.
-
Checking both tyres on one side it's 7.4 and the side it's 6.7 and this is on both tyres.
Michelin says "not right, take back and get changed"
-
Conti 5Ps are great tyres. Served me very well on GTI's and R over last 5 years. Michelin PS4S are better - on another level and worth it for the rescued noise and superlative pothole absorbing qualities alone, never mind the astonishing level of grip in wet and dry. Have actually transformed my daily commute.
Luckily motor came with 5Ps and although feel fine they are on the noisy side but for sure will go the PS4S route when requires. Always loved Michies, were the only real choice years back, fantastic on the Clio Williams.
Out of interest, any R owners bother with winter tyres these days, recall some did on the Mk6 mainly North of the border though.
Yes many R owners bother with winter tyres and winter wheels too, you'll find it's a topic of seasonal discussion on the R forum if you ever pop your head in there. :smiley:
I've found winter tyres a must on my GTI.
Why?
-
Checking both tyres on one side it's 7.4 and the side it's 6.7 and this is on both tyres.
Michelin says "not right, take back and get changed"
Seems quite common if you Google it...