GolfGTIforum.co.uk

Model specific boards => Golf mk4 => Topic started by: TS Jasma on 19 April 2009, 19:45

Title: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: TS Jasma on 19 April 2009, 19:45
Ok, so looking like im going to sell my 130bhp tdi to my sister, n im thinking of going for a v6,but to be honest i dont know if its worth changing from the gttdi to the a v6 4 motion.

so this is me being stoopid, n asking if theres any vast differences that would make it worth the change if i do sell my current golf to my sister.

 :smiley:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: richw911 on 19 April 2009, 19:47
Keep the derv or get a 1.8T  :laugh:

V6 is a nice car tho TBH  :cool: :cool:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Rhyso on 19 April 2009, 19:47
don't bother  :grin: :grin:

get it remapped.....

(http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y276/Rhyso/R-TechRRDay.jpg)



Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Steve_PD on 19 April 2009, 19:55
how many miles you do a year??
How about buying a v6 4mo and swapping engines to have a PD130 4mo and a V6 2mo  :grin: :cool:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: TS Jasma on 19 April 2009, 19:57
Would it be worth remapping my gttdi? like, wont my insurance company frown on it more as its a modified car, rather than if i bought a v6, which im sure would burn a hole in my pokcet for feul.

see if i keep my car, i really want to do something to make it look special, but body kitting it falls into the moding zone again.
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Rhyso on 19 April 2009, 19:59
Would it be worth remapping my gttdi? like, wont my insurance company frown on it more as its a modified car, rather than if i bought a v6, which im sure would burn a hole in my pokcet for feul.

see if i keep my car, i really want to do something to make it look special, but body kitting it falls into the moding zone again.

Remap HAS TO BE DONE  :cool:

depends how you're with re your insurance - mine went up about £90 or so i think

body modifications aren't adding power to the car which is what insurance companies tend to frown upon

why not get some quotes so you can decide what to do  :smiley:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: richw911 on 19 April 2009, 20:01
Would it be worth remapping my gttdi? like, wont my insurance company frown on it more as its a modified car, rather than if i bought a v6, which im sure would burn a hole in my pokcet for feul.

see if i keep my car, i really want to do something to make it look special, but body kitting it falls into the moding zone again.

Get it mapped then some nice wheels maybe drop it a bit  :cool:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Steve_PD on 19 April 2009, 20:02
Go with HIC, engine mods will put the price up but body mods and suspension didn't on mine  :wink:

Would it be worth remapping my gttdi? like, wont my insurance company frown on it more as its a modified car, rather than if i bought a v6, which im sure would burn a hole in my pokcet for feul.

see if i keep my car, i really want to do something to make it look special, but body kitting it falls into the moding zone again.

Get it mapped then some nice wheels maybe drop it a bit  :cool:

Then some rear lights, exhaust, interior mods............. :laugh:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: TS Jasma on 19 April 2009, 20:03
thanks rhyso..

i considered a mk5 gti, but i had one for two weeks as a hire vehicle when mine got a ding. was good, but im not sure, thats a car that needsss playing with, but looks so good when done right.

hmm, see im kinda blonde with insurance as far as body mods are n remaps. if it wouldnt effect me on a kit id put an r32 bod on it, but im sure it will hit high if i do that on my insurance.

hmm, confuzzeled! :laugh:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: richw911 on 19 April 2009, 20:07
thanks rhyso..

i considered a mk5 gti, but i had one for two weeks as a hire vehicle when mine got a ding. was good, but im not sure, thats a car that needsss playing with, but looks so good when done right.

hmm, see im kinda blonde with insurance as far as body mods are n remaps. if it wouldnt effect me on a kit id put an r32 bod on it, but im sure it will hit high if i do that on my insurance.

hmm, confuzzeled! :laugh:

Ring some one like www.adrianflux.co.uk who are mod friendly and ask you may be surprised  :wink:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Khare on 19 April 2009, 20:10
remap gttdi. Just look at rhysos torque!  :shocked:

And a chipped gttdi will probably be far cheaper on insurance than a v6 4mo anyway, even if the gttdi had an R32 bodykit.

Id stick with a gttdi purely because of cost. v6 4mo is £400/year to tax, and it drinks petrol at a nice fast rate, yet a gttdi will be economical (more economical after a remap infact if driven sensibly) and tax will be cheaper.
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Rhyso on 19 April 2009, 20:12
remap gttdi. Just look at rhysos torque!  :shocked:

And a chipped gttdi will probably be far cheaper on insurance than a v6 4mo anyway, even if the gttdi had an R32 bodykit.

Id stick with a gttdi purely because of cost. v6 4mo is £400/year to tax, and it drinks petrol at a nice fast rate, yet a gttdi will be economical (more economical after a remap infact if driven sensibly) and tax will be cheaper.

 :smug: :smug: (allow for rolling road inaccuracy mind)

on my run to work (20 miles) i can easily see 55mpg + :afro:

long term average is holding steady at around 50mpg - thats with 18inch wheels too  :smiley:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Steve_PD on 19 April 2009, 20:14
remap gttdi. Just look at rhysos torque!  :shocked:

And a chipped gttdi will probably be far cheaper on insurance than a v6 4mo anyway, even if the gttdi had an R32 bodykit.

Id stick with a gttdi purely because of cost. v6 4mo is £400/year to tax, and it drinks petrol at a nice fast rate, yet a gttdi will be economical (more economical after a remap infact if driven sensibly) and tax will be cheaper.

Good luck  :laugh: :laugh: :laugh:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Ivor Mk4 Turbo on 19 April 2009, 20:15
Don't forget to budget for a £900 clutch upgrade if you get it mapped! :P
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Steve_PD on 19 April 2009, 20:16
Don't forget to budget for a £900 clutch upgrade if you get it mapped! :P

And a big bag of cable ties  :lipsrsealed: :grin:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Rhyso on 19 April 2009, 20:17
Don't forget to budget for a £900 clutch upgrade if you get it mapped! :P

And a big bag of cable ties  :lipsrsealed: :grin:

yep then you can upgrade again and go hybrid turbo  :tongue: :grin: :grin:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Ivor Mk4 Turbo on 19 April 2009, 20:21
Then she may as well just have bought an R32!! :D
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Rhyso on 19 April 2009, 20:23
Then she may as well just have bought an R32!! :D

where's the fun in that though?  :undecided: :evil:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Khare on 19 April 2009, 20:24
remap gttdi. Just look at rhysos torque!  :shocked:

And a chipped gttdi will probably be far cheaper on insurance than a v6 4mo anyway, even if the gttdi had an R32 bodykit.

Id stick with a gttdi purely because of cost. v6 4mo is £400/year to tax, and it drinks petrol at a nice fast rate, yet a gttdi will be economical (more economical after a remap infact if driven sensibly) and tax will be cheaper.

Good luck  :laugh: :laugh: :laugh:

in what??  :huh:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: richw911 on 19 April 2009, 20:25
Then she may as well just have bought an R32!! :D

where's the fun in that though?  :undecided: :evil:

Ask bob  :laugh:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: richw911 on 19 April 2009, 20:26
remap gttdi. Just look at rhysos torque!  :shocked:

And a chipped gttdi will probably be far cheaper on insurance than a v6 4mo anyway, even if the gttdi had an R32 bodykit.

Id stick with a gttdi purely because of cost. v6 4mo is £400/year to tax, and it drinks petrol at a nice fast rate, yet a gttdi will be economical (more economical after a remap infact if driven sensibly) and tax will be cheaper.

Good luck  :laugh: :laugh: :laugh:

in what??  :huh:

Driving sensible after a remap  :grin:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Khare on 19 April 2009, 20:27
remap gttdi. Just look at rhysos torque!  :shocked:

And a chipped gttdi will probably be far cheaper on insurance than a v6 4mo anyway, even if the gttdi had an R32 bodykit.

Id stick with a gttdi purely because of cost. v6 4mo is £400/year to tax, and it drinks petrol at a nice fast rate, yet a gttdi will be economical (more economical after a remap infact if driven sensibly) and tax will be cheaper.

Good luck  :laugh: :laugh: :laugh:

in what??  :huh:

Driving sensible after a remap  :grin:
ahh right yeah! Its all about self control.
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Ivor Mk4 Turbo on 19 April 2009, 20:27
Then she may as well just have bought an R32!! :D

where's the fun in that though?  :undecided: :evil:


Ok, ok.......................  She'll have to charge it! :D

At least the R 'handles' straight out of the box! 8)
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: sambo on 19 April 2009, 20:36
Who cares about the car, got any more pic's!?  :tongue:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Steve_PD on 19 April 2009, 21:09
remap gttdi. Just look at rhysos torque!  :shocked:

And a chipped gttdi will probably be far cheaper on insurance than a v6 4mo anyway, even if the gttdi had an R32 bodykit.

Id stick with a gttdi purely because of cost. v6 4mo is £400/year to tax, and it drinks petrol at a nice fast rate, yet a gttdi will be economical (more economical after a remap infact if driven sensibly) and tax will be cheaper.

Good luck  :laugh: :laugh: :laugh:

in what??  :huh:

Driving sensible after a remap  :grin:

Its very hard  :lipsrsealed: :laugh: :laugh:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: paulyV6 on 19 April 2009, 21:19
My 4mo isn't £400 a year tax - it's £180ish, the exact same as my mk2 GTI.

It's a 2000 model, but as far as I know, none of them are £400 a year tax......

I've just checked on Parkers - pre 2001 cars will only be going up to £205 per year tax, while post 2001 will be £245.  Hardly extortionate!?!?!

http://www.parkers.co.uk/cars/road-tax/?deriv=18512 (http://www.parkers.co.uk/cars/road-tax/?deriv=18512)

Anyway - yeah it is juicy, but not stupidly so - about what you'd expect from a 2.8 V6 with the power going through all four wheels really!  I usually get about 26mpg on my way to work - 14 miles on B roads with about 2 miles of dual carriageway thrown in for fun (it's usually below 20mpg on the way home from work).  I've got to the dizzy heights of 33mpg on a long motorway journey before though.

There's some bargain 4motions to be had out there too as people get scared that they're not going to be able to afford to run them with the fuel going up in price.  Mine was advertised for £5250 and I ended up haggling him down to £3700.  To be honest, I haven't noticed the difference going from having a mk2 as my daily to having the 4motion.

Remember, diesel is for tractors and lorries - V6 power is where it's at.

Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Khare on 19 April 2009, 21:31
thought the v6 were a 3.2l, which is £400 per year i believe.
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: paulyV6 on 19 April 2009, 21:36
V6 4motion is a 2.8, R32 is a 3.2 V6 (also with Haldex 4motion system).

Anyway - the mk4 R32 is also not £400 per year tax: http://www.parkers.co.uk/cars/road-tax/?deriv=24062 (http://www.parkers.co.uk/cars/road-tax/?deriv=24062) it's going up to £245 the same as the 2.8!

When the govt introduced their thieving tax hikes last year, all post 2001 cars were going to be £450 from 2010.  They swiftly back tracked - the rates in the above link are the up to date ones.

I taxed my 4mo this month, so got in at the old rates (it's going up slightly from May this year).
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Khare on 19 April 2009, 22:07
where did i read that R32 costs £400 to insure then  :huh:
ah well.
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: paulyV6 on 19 April 2009, 22:15
You probably read it at the end of last year???????

They introduced the new tax hikes around September time, then had a little re-think about November time.  Both the 4motion and the R32 were supposed to go into the top £450 per year tax bracket if they were registered after 1st April 2001.  It's why I made sure when I bought mine that it was registered before then (December 2000) and would be in the old tax code.
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Khare on 19 April 2009, 22:25
no i read it today on the forums, but no idea what topic  :grin:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Ivor Mk4 Turbo on 19 April 2009, 22:29
Who cares about the car, got any more pic's!?  :tongue:


+1!!!

She looks like a right cheeky minx! :P  (http://i42.photobucket.com/albums/e345/ivormk4/Smileys/hyper.gif)
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: northeast_gti-t on 19 April 2009, 22:34


Remember, diesel is for tractors and lorries - V6 power is where it's at.


Remapped 1.8T where it's at :afro:  :grin:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: paulyV6 on 19 April 2009, 23:53
What about a remapped 4motion?  The engine's not as receptive to it as the 1.8T, but you're starting at 204 anyway.  I think you're looking at around 220 with a stage 1 and obviously more with exhaust/CAI and higher stage map.
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Rhyso on 20 April 2009, 07:52


Remember, diesel is for tractors and lorries - V6 power is where it's at.


Remapped 1.8T where it's at :afro:  :grin:

don't make me post my graph again Matt  :evil: :laugh: :laugh:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: johnson6672 on 20 April 2009, 08:43
Tax all goes on Co2 readings, the goverment are putting it up, they just delayed it, 225g/km and over is going to be £400 i thyink, and i am pretty sure the 4mo is above the 225g/km level, below 225g/km is going to be £300 or there abouts, and anything pre 2000 (oct i think) is one flat rate (£195 at the moment i think although this is also going up aswell, most cars around 2.0l are going to be in the £300 a year box and most 2.5l and above are in the £400 a year box, thats as a rough guide anyway.
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: paulyV6 on 20 April 2009, 12:36
Right - it seems that there's a few people who are incapable of clicking the rather handy link I posted (http://www.parkers.co.uk/cars/road-tax/?deriv=18512 (http://www.parkers.co.uk/cars/road-tax/?deriv=18512)) showing the current 4motion tax, what it's going up to from May 09 and what it's going up to from April 2010.

So here it is in table form - you don't even have to click anything, just read and digest.  Tax for the 4motion and the mk4 R32 for that matter is not going to be anywhere near £400 a year as it stands.

Volkswagen Golf Hatchback (97-04) 2.8 V6 4MOTION 3d

Rates effective from 13 March 2008

Date of Registration              6 Months       12 Months       Band        CO2 (g/km)

5 Jan 2000 – 1 Mar 2001       £101.75         £185.00           -
1 Mar 2001 – 1 Jan 2004       £115.50         £210.00           F                264

Rates effective from May 2009

Date of Registration              6 Months       12 Months       Band        CO2 (g/km)

5 Jan 2000 – 1 Mar 2001       £104.50         £190.00           -
1 Mar 2001 – 1 Jan 2004       £118.25         £215.00           K                264

Rates effective from April 2010

Date of Registration              6 Months       12 Months       Band        CO2 (g/km)

5 Jan 2000 – 1 Mar 2001       £112.75         £205.00           -
1 Mar 2001 – 1 Jan 2004       £134.75         £245.00           K                264


As the R32 wasn't registered until August 2002, it does not qualify for the "old" tax bracket for pre April 2001 cars.  It does however, still fall into new Band K which means that it's only going up to £245.00 per year in April 2010 the same as the 4motion.

The website can be found here - http://www.parkers.co.uk/cars/road-tax/ (http://www.parkers.co.uk/cars/road-tax/) and you can put any car in to find out what you'll be paying in tax in the coming years.
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: topher on 20 April 2009, 12:45
Only R32's registered after April 2006 are subject to the £400+ tax.

Mine was regsitered May 2006 :undecided:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Khare on 20 April 2009, 16:40
Only R32's registered after April 2006 are subject to the £400+ tax.

Mine was regsitered May 2006 :undecided:
see, so SOME R32s do have to pay £400 tax.  :tongue:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: T_J_G on 20 April 2009, 16:43
Only R32's registered after April 2006 are subject to the £400+ tax.

Mine was regsitered May 2006 :undecided:
see, so SOME R32s do have to pay £400 tax.  :tongue:

But those are Mk5's and not Mk4's. And we're in the mk4 section :p
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: paulyV6 on 20 April 2009, 17:29
Only R32's registered after April 2006 are subject to the £400+ tax.

Mine was regsitered May 2006 :undecided:
see, so SOME R32s do have to pay £400 tax.  :tongue:

But those are Mk5's and not Mk4's. And we're in the mk4 section :p

Exactly my Kentish friend - I quite clearly kept this mk4 relevant!!
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: T_J_G on 20 April 2009, 17:32
Only R32's registered after April 2006 are subject to the £400+ tax.

Mine was regsitered May 2006 :undecided:
see, so SOME R32s do have to pay £400 tax.  :tongue:

But those are Mk5's and not Mk4's. And we're in the mk4 section :p

Exactly my Kentish friend - I quite clearly kept this mk4 relevant!!

 :cool:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: johnson6672 on 20 April 2009, 20:30
So have the goverment done a u turn then?
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Steve_PD on 20 April 2009, 20:56
for the time being, until the recession is over  :wink:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Rhyso on 20 April 2009, 20:57
for the time being, until the recession is over  :wink:

which is Christmas time apparently  :rolleyes:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: johnson6672 on 20 April 2009, 21:00
I thought so cause the last i heard my scoobie was going to cost me £300 a year in tax, but also my wifes old Focus 2.0l was going to be the same.
Well thats a relief for the time being, still getting rid of the Jap crap though and getting me a piece good old German engineering or 2.
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Steve_PD on 20 April 2009, 21:01
if you listen to them bastards in number 10  :angry: :angry:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Rhyso on 20 April 2009, 21:02
still getting rid of the Jap crap though and getting me a piece good old German engineering or 2.

 :lipsrsealed:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: Steve_PD on 20 April 2009, 21:14
I thought so cause the last i heard my scoobie was going to cost me £300 a year in tax, but also my wifes old Focus 2.0l was going to be the same.
Well thats a relief for the time being, still getting rid of the Jap crap though and getting me a piece good old German engineering or 2.

Jab crap  :huh: never had any problems with jab cars, but the golf on the other hand  :lipsrsealed: :lipsrsealed: :laugh:
Title: Re: gttdi or v6 4motion
Post by: johnson6672 on 20 April 2009, 21:18
3rd Gear mashed, need either repair, recon or breakers, loooking minimum £600, partly my own fault, driving it far too hard far to much, but hey if you got it you might aswell use it properley!