Author Topic: Buying used: what cosmetic imperfections to accept  (Read 4647 times)

Offline James_H

  • Just got here
  • *
  • Posts: 4
Buying used: what cosmetic imperfections to accept
« on: 28 September 2008, 18:38 »
Hello all.

I'm a bit of a lurker on this forum as not yet an owner but have stepped up my search for a Mk5 GTI DSG.  I did see one this weekend that ticked a lot of boxes.  My main reservation was the exterior marks.  Nothing was major, but it had  :cry::
- A scratch down the length of one side, the type left by a bag or coat rather than a key, though I struggled to feel it with my nail.
- A small dent on the rear n/s wing that had also chipped the paint.
- Paint chip on the front bumper
- A couple of chips out of the paint on the edge of the drivers door.
- All the 18-inch Monza IIs had seen some scuffing, not on the face of the wheel but the on the edge.
- The wheel studs had this odd white stuff on them.

From reading past threads on here, I realise most of you are like me and take great care of our cars and get miffed at the tiniest of chips.  I'm the sort with carpet on my garage walls, would rather scuff my knuckles by putting my finger round the door edge than open the dorr against a wall etc.  That said, I have the benefit of running two cars and the Golf would be replacing my practical car that sits outside.  Despite taking great care with that, it has suffered from being kept outdoors and does have the odd marks inflicted by bird lime or less considerate parkers/pedestrians.

My question is for those of you who bought used, how much in the way of minor cosmetic damage did you find acceptable and were there many cars that you turned down?

The car I saw was at a dealer (independent, not a VW franchise).  The thing that bothers me about the light scratch down the side is that it is clear the car has seen some form of polish or wax because of the residue around the door handles.  If the scratches would polish out, for the cost of a bit of elbow grease, why have they not been done. 

I (or the dealer) could always get someone in to sort the chips, though the one with the dent could cause difficulty.

Most of these concerns apply to any car, but particular to the GTI are the Monza IIs, which by design are just asking to be kerbed by a less diligent driver.  I've read all about difficulty of refurbing and also the white worm, of which there is only a tiny bit of evidence on the offside rear.  Quite how that wheel has been scuffed I don't know.  The nearside front normally takes the brunt, yet all are fairly even on this car.  The scuffs rule out any warranty replacement and now the scuffs are there the condition will only deteriorate.  However, with relatively little visible damage, I don't think it's worth getting them done (or getting the dealer to) straight away, particularly as I may kerb them once or twice again the early weeks of ownership, as always seems to be the case.  Is a set of perfect Monza IIs the holy grail so that I should revise my expectations down?

The centre caps were going, but that could be a warranty fix.  Anyone know what would make the wheel studs go a mixture of black and white?

Sorry for the long post.  I'm making up for having done much more reading than writing.  :nerd:

Offline 182_blue

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 2,750
Re: Buying used: what cosmetic imperfections to accept
« Reply #1 on: 28 September 2008, 18:53 »
Well what you accept is upto you, i wouldn't personally want scratches (well not past the clearcoat), repainted panels, scuffed alloys, cig burns, worn seats etc, an odd small dent may be ok if i could get it out, i suppose allot depends on how much you have to spend too, i would shop around as with a new model coming out there will be some mint well priced motors out there

how much you spending

Offline 182_blue

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 2,750
Re: Buying used: what cosmetic imperfections to accept
« Reply #2 on: 28 September 2008, 18:55 »
Ps the wheels should have caps over the bolts, are the bolts showing ?, or is it the plastic caps your seeing ?

like this


Offline Hurdy

  • Serious forum addict
  • *
  • Posts: 8,466
Re: Buying used: what cosmetic imperfections to accept
« Reply #3 on: 28 September 2008, 20:09 »
Welcome to the forum James. :cool:

Buying second hand is always a slight gamble, but there are gems out there to be bought.

Buying a car that is mechanically right is the main thing, cosmetic imperfections are what you would have to negotiate on if you were to buy. :wink:
Seat Leon Cupra Black 290 DSG

Offline ub7rm

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,476
Re: Buying used: what cosmetic imperfections to accept
« Reply #4 on: 28 September 2008, 20:22 »
When I viewed my car I spotted some scuffs on the mirrors, some scratches on the rear bumper and the interior trim on the tailgate was broken and I asked for all of that to be sorted - which it was (main dealer BTW).

However when I came to washing the car properly myself I've noticed quite a few stone chips / scratches that once you spot them the first time they then seem to stare out at you.  When I was looking at it in the dealer my heart was ruling not my head!  However now I know about them it detracts a bit from the excitement of owning the car.  I part exed an 8 year old car that was in nigh on mint condition which seems to make it worse.

So if you think you're the type of person to feel a bit unhappy that your car isn't in perfect condition I would keep looking or insist that they are sorted.  Don't get too carried away and do something that you will regret or at least will cost you more money later on when you decide you cant live with it.

And welcome!
2020 BMW 128ti
2017 Golf GTD Estate

Offline neg

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 927
Re: Buying used: what cosmetic imperfections to accept
« Reply #5 on: 28 September 2008, 20:39 »
No car is perfect - even brand new.

Accept what you feel you will be happy with.  Mine had a couple of minor marks on it when I got it - but nothing obvious and something that could easily have been done after a days driving.  Stone chips on the front - thats what you get for using your car ;)

Wheels are nothing to worry about and shouldnt stop you buying a good example - just factor in the cost and get the refurbished yourself

Offline stealthwolf

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,056
Re: Buying used: what cosmetic imperfections to accept
« Reply #6 on: 28 September 2008, 23:26 »
- The wheel studs had this odd white stuff on them.

Mine has that on some of the wheel bolt covers too. On one or two, it seems to have come off when I detailed the car but some of the others, it's still on. I wonder whether it's the remnant of some kind of cleaner or polish that was left on too long or never washed off properly.

My question is for those of you who bought used, how much in the way of minor cosmetic damage did you find acceptable and were there many cars that you turned down?

TBH I bought my car on the same day as seeing it. It was 8mth old ex-demo. Perfect condition. Didn't notice 1. lack of wheelbolt cover remover tool 2. white stuff on wheel bolt covers 3. front offside alloy different tint to the others until after I'd already bought the car. None of them bothers me but wish I'd known about the alloy colour difference, since I would have haggled down or asked for a matching alloy.

Offline wellzee

  • GTI forum regular
  • ***
  • Posts: 125
Re: Buying used: what cosmetic imperfections to accept
« Reply #7 on: 29 September 2008, 04:53 »
James, it really depends on the age of the car your looking at, and if the marks on it are reflected in the price. If the car is 07 onwards I would say that is an awful lot of damage for such a period of time. Even so, it seems like quite a bit even if its an older model. I have just sold my old 55 plate civic and the only marks on the exterior were 3 or 4 stone chips. Granted I am fairly protective, but still all those things you list do make it seem like perhaps the car hasnt had the most loving previous owner.

However, as some guys have already said, you could definately have a go at trying to get the dealer to agree to sort out at least some of them as a clincher to you agreeing to buy. HTH.


Black 08 GTi - 18" Monza II's, Leather, Centre Arm Rest, Parking Sensors - Love It!

Offline WobGTI

  • GTI forum regular
  • ***
  • Posts: 222
Re: Buying used: what cosmetic imperfections to accept
« Reply #8 on: 29 September 2008, 11:03 »
You have to accept the condition of the vehicle based on the age of it...

I think chips on the bonnet/bumper on a 3yr old car are pretty much accepted...

I'm trying to learn to judge wear on car keys too as you can tell the mileage of a car based on the car key as there's so many people who clock their cars for company car mileage...

Also worth checking the seats for wear too...

You need to look at the car and think, if I was selling this on to someone else, what would someone look to discount the car based on the condition of x.y.z.

Also take into account whether it comes with Tax/MOT/Recent Service/New Tyres as thats an instant £900ish if it has 12mths on all three....

But if it needs Tax/MOT/Service & depending what needs doing on the service you could find yourself £900 out of pocket as soon as you buy the thing!
Mk5 GTI | Full Leather | Winter Pack


http://www.symesmini.com
http://www.pinkmini.com

Offline Teutonic_Tamer

  • Forum addict
  • *
  • Posts: 4,562
  • GreasedMonkey - HoofHearted - GTI now mod'ed, ASK!
Re: Buying used: what cosmetic imperfections to accept
« Reply #9 on: 29 September 2008, 12:05 »
Hello all.

Hi James.  A warm welcome to the forum.  :smiley:

I'm a bit of a lurker on this forum as not yet an owner but have stepped up my search for a Mk5 GTI DSG.

You don't actually have to own a GTI to post away here!  :wink:  :tongue:  So get posting away, and enjoy arguably the most knowledgeable and friendly Golf forums on the planet!  :nerd:  :grin:

- The wheel studs had this odd white stuff on them.

The centre caps were going, but that could be a warranty fix.  Anyone know what would make the wheel studs go a mixture of black and white?

If the wheel bolts did not have those little black covers on them, and they had a white furry substance, not too disimilar to limescale, then that is relatively normal.  It is basically galvanic corrosion, and is caused when two different metals contact each other (the cast iron of the brake disc, the aluminium alloy of the wheel, and the steel of the bolt).  :nerd:

When you get the car, slaken the bolts, jack up the car.  Carefully remove the wheel.  Wire brush the mounting face of the disc, and the wheel bolts, and very carefully do the same to the mounting face of the alloy.  Then smear a thin layer of anti-sieze paste in the mounting face of the wheel to disc, and also the apply the same on the bolt threads and concial seat of the bolt.
Sean - Independent Automotive Engineering Technician (ret'd)
-----
'06/7 Golf Mk5 GTI 5dr (BWA) DSG, colour coded,

I feel like a homo