classic question

[Hurdy]

5dr is more practical for living with long term, but 3 dr is more aesthetically pleasing.

5dr edges it for me

[golfgtidan]

i have a 5 door, wouldnt swop it for a 3 door, its to practical. couldnt deal with getting in and out to let people in/out all the time.

[bobbarley]

5 door GTI's are faster than 3 door ones.....



Honest 

 

[GTi-Matt]

5 door GTI's are faster than 3 door ones.....



Honest 

 

tell that to rich!!!!!

[richw911]

5 door GTI's are faster than 3 door ones.....



Honest 

 

tell that to rich!!!!!

Your two extra doors weigh more than my bigger two doors 

[ub7rm]

Had a 5 door mk4 and when it came to :cough: upgrading to a mk5 even thought the three door looks much better I couldn't loose that practicality.  Moved house and all sorts of crap in the mk4 and wouldn't have been able to do that with a 3dr.  Couldn't be assed with getting in and out to let passengers in / out either.  5dr for me......

[T_J_G]

shouldn't even be thinking of 5 doors 

[gooseuk]

3 doors looks better. But for normal people with mates and has to cart sh!t around alot then its 5door. So 5 ftw

[T_J_G]

I'v only ever had 3 doors and cart mates and gear (music related) around. And I mean lots of gear. the mk4 boot swallows quite alot!

[Ivor Mk4 Turbo]

5 doors look weird on med. size hatchbacks!

3 doors look llllllllluuuuuuuuuurrrrrrrrrrrvvvvvvvvvvveeeeeeeeerrrrrrrrrllllllllyyyyyyyyyy!!!

5 doors are also heavier & the chassis flex's more!!