I like the S3. It has the four wheel drive the Edition 30 so badly needs and i nmy opinion looks better inside and out than any other similarly sized VAG car.
I also like BMW's, but would not have one unless it was the 135i, 335i, 335D. Not going to include things like the Z4M (ugly) or the M5/M6 as I would spend that much money on something different.
One thing that is funny is that when you go round the car forums, you get the anti this and anti that, Surprised that so many on here are ripping in to BMW's and Audi for that matter.