Author Topic: edition 30 vs R32  (Read 36043 times)

Peskarik

  • Guest
Re: edition 30 vs R32
« Reply #130 on: 04 December 2007, 19:15 »
Why not pick a comparable basis for establishing which model is numero uno, like OTR price excluding extras?

why is there a need to establish who is numero uno? Audi S3 will kill both E30 and R32, anyway, for example...

But thats not what this thread is about... if we wanted to compare the S3 then the title of the thread would have said so.

oooo.. do you want a lolly?

Peskarik

  • Guest
Re: edition 30 vs R32
« Reply #131 on: 04 December 2007, 19:17 »
If it's about "top of the range" then that is presumably the highest priced basic spec car. 

As for best car, well that's a matter of opinion.

Cherry Amulet is the best car for kicks!  :smiley:

Peskarik

  • Guest
Re: edition 30 vs R32
« Reply #132 on: 04 December 2007, 19:19 »
anyway, remember TOp Gear? They all chose Alfa 147 GTA over R32!  :cool:

DannyBoyR32

  • Guest
Re: edition 30 vs R32
« Reply #133 on: 04 December 2007, 19:38 »
listen i asked my mum as well

she says the r32 is much better  :grin:

lol...if it werent the better car, wouldnt it be cheaper?? it also wouldnt be the "flagship" model of the Golfs.... :smiley:

You could equally say as the ED30 is the anniversary version of the ultimate GTI...isn't that the "flagship" model?

ultimate gti?? maybe! Flagship golf?? not!
stop being a baby. You've got the best Golf there is, are you happy now?

flagship smhagship  :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :cry: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin: :grin:

Offline R32UK

  • Forum addict
  • *
  • Posts: 5,683
Re: edition 30 vs R32
« Reply #134 on: 04 December 2007, 19:40 »
anyway, remember TOp Gear? They all chose Alfa 147 GTA over R32!  :cool:

Cough cough.. OLD R32!!

It doesnt come close to the new one... It was approx 5sec slower round the TG track. Im quite sure that if VW wanted to make a 250bhp gti then they could quite easily do so. the problem would be with many of the other components the golf uses. Alfa's on the other hand break down so frequently... they didnt bother with the rest of the car and just churn as much power out as possible.

And they dont think the Alfa is the better car by the way.. :wink:
« Last Edit: 04 December 2007, 19:53 by R32UK »

Peskarik

  • Guest
Re: edition 30 vs R32
« Reply #135 on: 05 December 2007, 09:18 »
anyway, remember TOp Gear? They all chose Alfa 147 GTA over R32!  :cool:

Cough cough.. OLD R32!!

It doesnt come close to the new one... It was approx 5sec slower round the TG track. Im quite sure that if VW wanted to make a 250bhp gti then they could quite easily do so. the problem would be with many of the other components the golf uses. Alfa's on the other hand break down so frequently... they didnt bother with the rest of the car and just churn as much power out as possible.

And they dont think the Alfa is the better car by the way.. :wink:

but it goes to your HEART, Alfa.
I know what they mean

Offline R32UK

  • Forum addict
  • *
  • Posts: 5,683
Re: edition 30 vs R32
« Reply #136 on: 05 December 2007, 18:06 »
anyway, remember TOp Gear? They all chose Alfa 147 GTA over R32!  :cool:

Cough cough.. OLD R32!!

It doesnt come close to the new one... It was approx 5sec slower round the TG track. Im quite sure that if VW wanted to make a 250bhp gti then they could quite easily do so. the problem would be with many of the other components the golf uses. Alfa's on the other hand break down so frequently... they didnt bother with the rest of the car and just churn as much power out as possible.

And they dont think the Alfa is the better car by the way.. :wink:

but it goes to your HEART, Alfa.
I know what they mean
First it was the Qudi s3.. then the alfa.. something tells me you bought the wrong badge!! Alfa's are fine if your comparing them to something with no soul like a astra.. but we are talking a V6 VW here!!  Get it together boy!! :rolleyes:

Peskarik

  • Guest
Re: edition 30 vs R32
« Reply #137 on: 06 December 2007, 07:56 »
anyway, remember TOp Gear? They all chose Alfa 147 GTA over R32!  :cool:

Cough cough.. OLD R32!!

It doesnt come close to the new one... It was approx 5sec slower round the TG track. Im quite sure that if VW wanted to make a 250bhp gti then they could quite easily do so. the problem would be with many of the other components the golf uses. Alfa's on the other hand break down so frequently... they didnt bother with the rest of the car and just churn as much power out as possible.

And they dont think the Alfa is the better car by the way.. :wink:

but it goes to your HEART, Alfa.
I know what they mean
First it was the Qudi s3.. then the alfa.. something tells me you bought the wrong badge!! Alfa's are fine if your comparing them to something with no soul like a astra.. but we are talking a V6 VW here!!  Get it together boy!! :rolleyes:

ha ha! you are a funny dude! Alfa has no soul? Wel, you never had an Alfa then. Read any review of 147 GTA. First of all it has a V6, just like R32, and moreover Alfa's V6 is a beautiful piece, not only in terms of performance and sound (read ANY review of GTA and you will see them RAVING about that engine!), but in terms of looks as well. Design thru and thru, even where you don't really look. I mean, look into the cockpit! Fantastic seats and dials that start from 6 o'clock in a traditional Alfa way, hand stitched leather, mmm.

Remember what they said on TG:
"If you had a modicum of common sence you'd avoid Alfa and buy another car, a Golf (R32) probably".
"THis car is insane".
"So, a complete disaster? No, fabulous car, wonderful in every way! Wait, you said it would lose all of its value, it would fall apart, and you'd probably crash into a field. Yes, but there are other ways to look at Alfas.... IF you want to be sensible, go on a buss."

And they all chose Alfa, despite it being slower. Because it is exciting, it has real DRIVE (not the kind of "drive"  :rolleyes: you have in R32, where you zip from one place to the other effortlessly in any kind of weather).
We had an Alfa in our family, 164TS, it was not really fast, it was noisy, but I loved it, and my dad loved it, and my mom loved it!

I am happy with E30, though it can get pretty sweaty on wet surfaces, especially on tram tracks.  :shocked:
If I had the money when I bought my car, I would have bought S3. I really like it. Yeah, it does not have V6 roar, but I do not buy a car for its exhaust sound. I did not buy R32 because I just did not feel for it. I mean, I know all the facts about R32, but when I see it I feel nothing inside, when I saw a photo of GTI E30 I knew then and there that I would buy one of these.

Alfa 147GTA.. that was the car I wanted the most, I was raving about it.... unfortunately it did not happen. I wanted a new car, and these were no longer manufactured. Also, I got an offer I could not refuse on E30, and the VW mechanics are my acquaintances so I always know that my car is in good hands.
So Alfa was not to happen, but I LOVE them, simply LOVE them. Everytime I see a 147GTA drive by, I smile like a baby and look at it till it disappears from view.  :kiss: :laugh: :tongue:

Offline Manu_R32

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,566
Re: edition 30 vs R32
« Reply #138 on: 06 December 2007, 10:25 »
will this subject ever ever ever finish?? Its starting to get abit annoying and it just keeps drifting away into other subs....

OSIR Front Splitter - OSIR Rear Diffuser - RNS 510 - JL Audio Cleansweep - JL Audio 400/4 Amplifier - JL Audio ZR650 - Recaro Bucket Seats - 3.2 V6 of Pure Power!

Komenda

  • Guest
Re: edition 30 vs R32
« Reply #139 on: 06 December 2007, 11:28 »
 Time to lock it. R32UK summed it up on page 10