i've had a mk2'16v' and a mk1'c', both were nimble & fun, but neither had any refinement. the mk3 is leagues ahead when it comes to a comfortable relaxing car. its quiet & smooth and you can drive it for hours on the motorway without it tiring you out - my mk1 was so noisey and bumpy on the motorway, plus any sidewinds would have you fighting at the wheel. The mk2 was more refined, but still had a very very basic early 80's dash which upt me off another one, the mk3 dash is solid and much more modern. They look wicked on the outside too, esp when lowered. i love the look of a black mk3 gti because the tinted rear glass makes it even blacker, its such a cool car. i love mine more and more...