I've just had my renewal come through from Elephant, they quoted me £516 TPFT for me (8yrs driving, 3yrs no claims, clean license) and my wife (provisional license) on my 1.4 N reg Polo. But Admiral quoted me £430 and best still AA quoted me £331.
Interestingly all the quotes I got off Confused.com came out as about £10 higher than the quotes I did myself.
Gonna look into some more tomorrow.