Author Topic: Confirmation on Lease vs Purchase costings  (Read 7711 times)

Offline wigit

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,722
Re: Confirmation on Lease vs Purchase costings
« Reply #20 on: 18 January 2017, 21:56 »
The biggest thing affecting this is how long you will keep the car.  leasing is great if you get a special deal and happy to change again in 2 years..  however its still money after something you wont own.

If you like to keep cars longer then you will get the benefit of paying it off and therefore not having the ongoing cost, as well as the depreciation dropping off..

Horses for courses really - it only costs you wedge when you go and trade in and re-commit !

The logical thing is decide how long you want it and then see what is the cheapest way of achieving that.

I used to have your logic and then worked out how much a R dropped in 2.5 years so the decision was to lease it.

M2 on the other hand I bought out right

Offline drisser

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 524
Re: Confirmation on Lease vs Purchase costings
« Reply #21 on: 18 January 2017, 22:48 »
That's kind of my point really, if you buy anything new these days and change after 2 years you get stung, just look at used prices of R's. On the other hand if you buy and keep for 5 years plus and are happy to do so then you get your money's worth.

I have just paid off my 2015 330d finance and for me that is a main car and I wanted it bought and paid for and will likely keep it 5+ years so I bought new, specced exactly what I wanted and got max discount.  If I traded after 2 years I would have got slaughtered but with 120k miles on it at 7 years old it will still be worth ok money and / or do a job for me.

I ran a 2004 330ci for 6 months back in 2014, paid £6200 for it, sold it for £6500 and only put fuel in it.  If you are happy running a non brand new car you can do it for a lot less than even the best lease deals!

Daily drive - LCI BMW 330 D Estoril Blue & Saddle leather. M sport + Pack / Prof Nav / Head Up / Heated Seats
On the way - CS ed 40 tornado red, manual, 3 door
Weekend fun - low mileage portofino blue 1997 Fiat Coupe 20v Turbo
2017 Build Slot reserved for BMW M2

Offline Hertsman

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 727
Re: Confirmation on Lease vs Purchase costings
« Reply #22 on: 19 January 2017, 14:09 »
Apologies for hi jacking this thread (seems the best one to) for selfish purposes but know some really informed folk are on the MK 7 forum and need their general advice without starting new thread.

Landmark date coming up for Wife in October and I want to lease a Mini Cooper Chili Pack Auto for her as a surprise and could go to local dealer and just pay the price

expected mileage would be low, 5k at most, so it has me looking at lease but PCP also if the deal better?

So what seeking is best option on value to achieve a Mini Cooper Chili Pack Auto for October (so when best time to start process)

All advice greatly appreciated

The 'go to' guy on the BMW forums TRL (username) seems to recommend this guy when it comes to MINI's, same dealer group I'll assume: gareth.roberts@berrymini.co.uk maybe try dropping him a quick email to test the water.
Aside from that and as per the cheap £95 lease deals they did on GTI's very briefly last year the only other way of getting the very best price is when the leasing companies get a promotion deal from time to time. There were several deals on MINI's last year so it can be a matter of just keeping your eye keenly on the leasing company websites. The very best deals tend to be quite short lived.


We have a 53 plate Mini at moment, does less than 5 k a year and only has 50k on it, and we plan to give that to youngest as first car. The replacement for wife would do same miles likely.

So given the expected low mileage of 5k and the expected ownership of maybe 5 years then looking as maybe buying used with low mileage as will hopefully will source a car with options seeking.

Think leasing and PCP on new will not give the value given the low miles?

Still not sure, and will definitely test the waters with Gareth over all the options, so thanks for that name really appreciated.

Present - BMW 128Ti Alpine White, 18" Performance Tyres, Sun Protection Glass, Parking Assist, Heated Steering, Boston Trim, Split Folding Rear Seats, Electric Lumbar Support
- 2nd car: 2019 Golf R DSG Pure White 19" Black Pretoria, Privacy Glass, Rear View Camera, Dynaudio, Keyless
- 2019 Pure Grey GTI TCR 5 Door DSG Reifinitz Wheel DCC Climate Screen 90% Tint
- 2016 Lapiz Blue Golf R 5 Door DSG Pretoria DCC
- 2013 Pure White GTD 5 Door DSG DCC

Offline wigit

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,722
Re: Confirmation on Lease vs Purchase costings
« Reply #23 on: 20 January 2017, 10:36 »
If you want a laugh (you might also want to be sitting down) you should see how much a Civic Type R will cost you to lease over two years  :laugh:

Offline Exonian

  • Serious forum addict
  • *
  • Posts: 9,293
Re: Confirmation on Lease vs Purchase costings
« Reply #24 on: 20 January 2017, 16:32 »
Apologies for hi jacking this thread (seems the best one to) for selfish purposes but know some really informed folk are on the MK 7 forum and need their general advice without starting new thread.

Landmark date coming up for Wife in October and I want to lease a Mini Cooper Chili Pack Auto for her as a surprise and could go to local dealer and just pay the price

expected mileage would be low, 5k at most, so it has me looking at lease but PCP also if the deal better?

So what seeking is best option on value to achieve a Mini Cooper Chili Pack Auto for October (so when best time to start process)

All advice greatly appreciated

The 'go to' guy on the BMW forums TRL (username) seems to recommend this guy when it comes to MINI's, same dealer group I'll assume: gareth.roberts@berrymini.co.uk maybe try dropping him a quick email to test the water.
Aside from that and as per the cheap £95 lease deals they did on GTI's very briefly last year the only other way of getting the very best price is when the leasing companies get a promotion deal from time to time. There were several deals on MINI's last year so it can be a matter of just keeping your eye keenly on the leasing company websites. The very best deals tend to be quite short lived.


We have a 53 plate Mini at moment, does less than 5 k a year and only has 50k on it, and we plan to give that to youngest as first car. The replacement for wife would do same miles likely.

So given the expected low mileage of 5k and the expected ownership of maybe 5 years then looking as maybe buying used with low mileage as will hopefully will source a car with options seeking.

Think leasing and PCP on new will not give the value given the low miles?

Still not sure, and will definitely test the waters with Gareth over all the options, so thanks for that name really appreciated.
I've got a three year old Cooper D bought for wife and sons to roll around in which they love. It was the best BHP per £££ as far as insurance goes with teenagers on the insurance. That was bought as a very low mileage two year old car to replace an old GTI I'd had for years and years which was getting a bit unreliable in daily use.
I tend to keep an older car for main family use and have a newish project Golf for an ornament that gets cleaned more than it gets driven.
Until now that is!
Having decided that my R was depreciating several hundred pounds for every mile that it got used for, plus the (smallish) amount of interest I was paying on a personal loan on it too it was pointless keeping the Golf just to sit in the garage for months on end.

After several months of negotiations with different dealers I finally punted the R into the trade for a fair price and bought a hugely discounted ex-showroom Cooper S D which allowed me to pay off the loan and, in theory, have a car that will cost peanuts to run as it has a service plan for five years, breakdown cover for three years and only £20 a year to tax which is less painful than £180 when the thing spends 99% of its time locked in a garage.

So my experience with MINIs is that they used to be good buys new, like VW's did, as their depreciation used to be very slow and they were in high demand. Unlike a few years ago though they face much tougher competition in sales so initial discounts are available where as they weren't a few years ago. However that means initial depreciation is high until they get to a point where they seem to bottom out in value (just like Golf R's funnily enough) and then depreciation slows right down.

You can sometimes, if you time it just right, pick up pre-registered Coopers at really good prices but if you're going to keep the car for years and years and are prepared to roll your sleeves up then you can actually negotiate good discounts on them new at present. If you only plan on keeping it a few years I'd advise against getting a new one though if it has quite a few options as MINIs are hard cars to get a proper trade valuation on except through MINI dealers who will know that immediately a Chilli Pack adds £1k to the used value and so on. The general trade are unaware of that so struggle to value them correctly.
There was a Cooper S D in a local dealer to me over the summer which had a really fantastic spec on it, full JCW and all the packs that would have retailed at £29k new give or take a few hundred(!!). The garage had it up for nearly £18k at 2 years old but would have taken a lower offer on it which doesn't sound to terrible BUT if you put the car into CAP using just the reg the trade value on it was just £13k!! Run the trade value in the correct way for a MINI and it came out at just over £15k trade value...
‘25 8.5R, ‘23 8R, ‘20 8CS, ‘19 135iX, ‘19 TCR, ‘17 Ed40, ‘17 GTD, ‘15 7R, ‘13 GTI PP, ‘11 GTI, ‘09 GTI, ‘98 Ibiza Cupra, ‘05 GTI, ‘06 Polo GTI, ‘04 GT TDI, ‘05 Fabia vRS, ‘02 GTI T, ‘03 Ibiza TDI 130, ‘01 Leon 180, ‘89 mk2 16v, ‘99 Ibiza TDI, ‘96 VR6, ‘98 Ibiza TDI, ‘92 VR6, ‘88 mk2 8v, ‘92 Polo G40, ‘91 mk2 8v, ‘89 mk2 8v, 205 GTI 1.9, ‘83 mk1 GTI, ‘80 Scirocco GTI, plus some others I’ve forgotten