Author Topic: GTI owners that would have choice again: buy manual or DSG?  (Read 12413 times)

Offline Bubba Nutkin

  • Not said much yet
  • **
  • Posts: 49
Re: GTI owners that would have choice again: buy manual or DSG?
« Reply #10 on: 17 April 2016, 17:24 »
As the last poster says it personal preference but my thinking was as I intend to keep the car for years the manual would be cheaper to fix if anything goes wrong. I still see DSG as new technology 😳

I agree with this point.  I would add three others:
1. manual is cheaper
2. the heritage of the GTI suggests manual, does it not?  Bit like golf ball gear knob, and tartan seat cloth
3. I foresee a medium term future where all cars will be some sort of auto (perhaps manual available as a cost option, the opposite of now) - the GTI has a good manual 'box, so enjoy it while you can.
Bubba.
« Last Edit: 17 April 2016, 17:27 by Bubba Nutkin »
mk7 GTI now sold.  Gone but not forgotten.

Offline Jan DR

  • Not said much yet
  • **
  • Posts: 53
Re: GTI owners that would have choice again: buy manual or DSG?
« Reply #11 on: 17 April 2016, 17:24 »
Thank you all for the feedback!

On paper, the DSG should be the better option, and I like the continous power through acceleration. But I did a testdrive with a GTI DSG and I was dissapointed about the "manual" mode: the reaction speeds of the gearbox when you touch the "up" paddle.

For the daily commute (with quite some traffic), the DSG is attractive in combination with the dynamic cruise control: "follow to stop". But on the other hand: the purpose of a GTI is not for the comfort...

So still a hard choice, but good to read that there are people who are happy with their "manual" choice!
Golf 7 GTI TCR
Golf 6 GTI Cabrio

Offline gtiaps

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 633
Re: GTI owners that would have choice again: buy manual or DSG?
« Reply #12 on: 17 April 2016, 17:38 »
Thank you all for the feedback!

On paper, the DSG should be the better option, and I like the continous power through acceleration. But I did a testdrive with a GTI DSG and I was dissapointed about the "manual" mode: the reaction speeds of the gearbox when you touch the "up" paddle.

For the daily commute (with quite some traffic), the DSG is attractive in combination with the dynamic cruise control: "follow to stop". But on the other hand: the purpose of a GTI is not for the comfort...

So still a hard choice, but good to read that there are people who are happy with their "manual" choice!

Good luck on your choice of gearbox as already said the choice is yours for whatever reasons but you have read the pros and cons I've never had a problem with manuals but again myself personally it's the manual box all the time
2010 Candy White Scirocco 2.0 TDI
2016 Carbon Grey Gti 2.0 Fully Loaded

COLLECTED 29/4/2016 and well pleased with the GTI😆😆

Offline kalimon

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,751
  • My other car's a van
Re: GTI owners that would have choice again: buy manual or DSG?
« Reply #13 on: 17 April 2016, 17:58 »
I went for the manual box after a bit of pondering and the minute I drove it home I knew I'd made the right choice :wink:
5 DR Mk 7 GTI PP
Carbon Grey, Dynaudio, Car Net App, High Beam Assist, Rear View Camera. Collected 14/03/16

Offline Brenbo

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 977
Re: GTI owners that would have choice again: buy manual or DSG?
« Reply #14 on: 17 April 2016, 18:19 »
Another reason I did not get a DSG box over Manual, is the Manual is so good and much more involving.  I know the DSG can change gear a lot quicker than Manual and it makes the 0-60 time marginally quicker but the joy of using a Manual gearbox out weights all of it for me.  Especially as stated before on the many B roads in my local area.

Offline Exonian

  • Serious forum addict
  • *
  • Posts: 9,295
Re: GTI owners that would have choice again: buy manual or DSG?
« Reply #15 on: 17 April 2016, 18:42 »
I think the R would suit a DSG more than a GTI due to the very different power delivery.
BUT the main reason for getting a manual GTI is the golf ball gear knob. We'd been waiting over 20 years for them to put that back in production on a series GTI (not a special edition GTI) and that alone makes it worth saving £1400.

Oh, and the fact you can anticipate corners far better than a computer, can block change and have learned that it's bad to change gear mid bend as it upsets Mother Nature and Einstein all in one go unlike a... you get the message.
‘25 8.5R, ‘23 8R, ‘20 8CS, ‘19 135iX, ‘19 TCR, ‘17 Ed40, ‘17 GTD, ‘15 7R, ‘13 GTI PP, ‘11 GTI, ‘09 GTI, ‘98 Ibiza Cupra, ‘05 GTI, ‘06 Polo GTI, ‘04 GT TDI, ‘05 Fabia vRS, ‘02 GTI T, ‘03 Ibiza TDI 130, ‘01 Leon 180, ‘89 mk2 16v, ‘99 Ibiza TDI, ‘96 VR6, ‘98 Ibiza TDI, ‘92 VR6, ‘88 mk2 8v, ‘92 Polo G40, ‘91 mk2 8v, ‘89 mk2 8v, 205 GTI 1.9, ‘83 mk1 GTI, ‘80 Scirocco GTI, plus some others I’ve forgotten 

Offline 2014GTi

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,012
  • Das Auto
Re: GTI owners that would have choice again: buy manual or DSG?
« Reply #16 on: 17 April 2016, 19:05 »
I agree, manual for the GTI and DSG for the R :)
2014 Volkswagen Golf GTi
2004 Volkswagen Golf R32
2011 Volkswagen Polo Bluemotion
2001 SEAT Arosa TDi S
1999 John Cooper Mini Works S
2005 Vauxhall Astra SRI CDTi
2004 Volkswagen Golf R32
2002 Audi S3 quattro
1999 Peugeot 206 Grand Tourisme

Offline wantmygti

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,140
Re: GTI owners that would have choice again: buy manual or DSG?
« Reply #17 on: 17 April 2016, 19:40 »
I agree, manual for the GTI and DSG for the R :)

I think I'd second that. To me, some about the clubsport says it has to be a manual...
2017 GTi Clubsport arrived June 2017
2007 Shadow Blue GTi, sold on after 10 years ownership

Offline Bungleaio

  • Here all the time
  • ****
  • Posts: 328
Re: GTI owners that would have choice again: buy manual or DSG?
« Reply #18 on: 17 April 2016, 20:04 »
I like the DSG, I didn't even bother test driving a manual golf as I knew I wanted an auto box in my next car. I'm not bothered about the extra weight, the efficiency penalty is worth it to me too. The way it works with the cruise control is really useful in traffic too.

I don't think I'll go back to a manual for daily use again if I can help it.
Abarth 595 Turismo + Classic Mini + Triumph Street Triple RS
Did have 3door DBP GTI PP

Offline James86

  • Not said much yet
  • **
  • Posts: 27
Re: GTI owners that would have choice again: buy manual or DSG?
« Reply #19 on: 17 April 2016, 20:07 »
My daily commute contains 21 roundabouts EACH WAY.......add some rush hour traffic to this makes me never want a manual again!

Each to their own.  :smiley:
Current: 2011 BMW 120d Coupe

On Order: 2016 GTI PP DSG