I don't think the British climate warrants full winter tyres although every area will be different. We don't suffer with months of snow and ice but more colder temperatures. All weather tyres fit our climate better at the moment.
I've got my 2 daughters and wife winter tyres with alloys. The golf sadly misses out

Even if it is just for that one occasion when it snows heavily and you are thankful you have winter tyres. I just think it gives piece of mind.
The way I look at it is it doesn't cost me any more even although I have paid out for wheels for the winters to go on.
You can only wear one set of tyres out at a time so each set lasts longer then the wheels are sold when the car gets changed.
For them it also freshens up the look of the car twice a year as women can't resist a new set of shoes
