VW Solutions, with the same £2,399 (and 10% discount) deposit comes in at £414 per month over 24 months!
The GFV is £17,518 - assuming the car retains two thirds of its value at the two year mark, ie; £20k, the figues would be as follows:
PCH - £2,399 + 23 x £270 = £8,609
PCP (with 10% discount of retail) - £2,399 = 23 x £414 = £11,921 (less £2.5k ie difference in cars value and GFV) = £9,421.
Admittedly the PCH adds metallic paint - although a hard bargain may get that thrown in too with the PCP! If you were to squeeze a £200 discoutn the difference is only £200 and an optimist (and fastidious owner) might think he would get more than £20k for the car after 2 years in a private sale... not much in it from that point of view!