Guys thanks for all your feedback......all of you have mixed feelings and some have settled into the DSG from the word go

So looks like the only way will be to get her down and test drive both types of boxes, and in both Diesel and Petrol
I like the look of the GTI, with the exhausts pipes on either side, and there is just something about owning a Gti that puts a wee smile on your face. I have always said I will own a Gti later on in life and this is the time...(mid life thing)

The motor we have just now is a BMW X1....a totally differant car all together so will be a big change for the wife!!!
Once again guys thanks for your input and will report back with the results of our findings....
