I've been trialling the adaptive cruise all this week to see if it much worse or better than me driving manually. Usual trip home from work i.e.
Distance 16.3 miles - Cold start. Car set to Comfort mode in the driving profile (i.e have DCC dampers) and of course the car is DSG.
10-15 minutes from start of crawling at <5mph for the first ½ mile
Onto motorway for 10 miles (cruise set to 70mph) - normally the Motorway is really busy and typically average speeds are around the 55-65mph range, so the ACC manages this speed differential perfectly..
5 miles of 50mph single carriageway followed by the last 0.8 miles of urban 30mph (roundabouts - traffic lights etc).
In the current weather (circa <7°C) I typically get (driving manually) about 50-52mpg.
This week with the cruise set, I've been achieving exactly the same. So whilst it's no better on economy, it doesn't seem to penalise as much as the manual cruise used to on the Scirocco, and with the speeds on the motorways up and down every 500 yards it seems, it does make the journey home much more relaxed and safer.
The only thing I would change is the minimum distance to the car in front, which even set to minimum, leaves a huge gap and invites other cars to keep cutting in meaning the ACC keeps having to slow down and speed up. I appreciate the distance is probably set to a distance that the car is able to brake from without hitting the car in front should an emergency situation arise, but if driving manually, I would normally be at least a third closer and still well behind the car in front and not tailgating (which is a pet hate of mine), but I do feel is a tad on the "safe" side.