I'm the same Bear, would go for a darker red if that were going to be my colour of choice.
Funny you should mention about the colour of other peoples cars. We were out for a walk on Monday and parked up nearby we passed quite a few cars, quite a few of which were a focus of some model. One was an RS in green, another a pagan gold/green, and a red candy. We commented how they all looked good, but how we wouldn't want them for ourselves!
A lot of it is to do with how you would feel about putting up with something on an ongoing basis. I'd happily drive around in a Tornado Red GTI for the weekend, but wouldn't want to own one that colour.