Author Topic: Any anti-theists in the house?  (Read 5141 times)

Offline MS1COYS

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 820
  • Alfie 'H' 10-09-11
Re: Any anti-theists in the house?
« Reply #20 on: 14 October 2012, 23:00 »
Even if you eradicated the world of religion, it still wouldn't change anything other than the reason for the war. Remember that Kim Jong Il, Lenin, Stalin, Mao etc were all atheists. Millions died because of them.

Man will kill for whatever reason be it power, money, greed, hatred etc. Unless you address the cause you'll never stop war.

Nobodies disputing this. Everybody is capable of evil.....
Evolution Map / Longlife USA 80mm TBE w/100 cell Sports Cat / ITG Maxogen G60 / Forge Twintercooler/ Forge TB Hose / R8 Coilpacks / EBC D&G Front & Rear Discs / EBC Yellowstuff Pads / BSH PCV Kit / Poly Pro Front & Rear / W.A.L.K / APR Torque Arm / 034Motorsport Density Line Engine Mounts / Vibratechnics Subframe Mount / Vibratechnics Dogbone Bush

292bhp / 287lbft

Offline Skred

  • Not said much yet
  • **
  • Posts: 43
  • I like lamp...
Re: Any anti-theists in the house?
« Reply #21 on: 15 October 2012, 00:06 »
I go to church every week. I use my brain to form my opinions. I do not share those of Christopher Hitchens although I can see why he had them given how he interpreted religious wars, bad events etc.

But don't tar all Christians with the same brush if you happen to see an arrogant or ignorant few portrayed on US television.

You're entitled to your opinion and that's all cool with me. Some people need faith.

My mum is a born again Christian has been for 20 years, goes to a Baptist Church every week, worship practice every Friday night and whilst I love her as any son should do, she is one of the more delusional people that I have ever met.

Believes the world is between 6,000 and 12,000 years old. Thinks Dinosaurs are only a few thousand years old. Doesn't believe in evolution, you get my drift hopefully.....



Then I would also be regarded as delusional I guess. Being a christian makes sense to me though and while I believe it shouldn't be rammed down other people's throats, if it is true (which I obviously do), then surely it shouldn't be kept a private thing.

And by your own admission, people do have bad in them which tells that the bible is correct in that regard.

Hitchens was highly intelligent. He was a skilled speaker and could verbally attack like next to no one else. And truth be told, if I saw things the way he did, I might agree with him. But as it happens, I have listened to others, I have taken time to think things through for myself and I just don't agree with him.

And for what it's worth, I have yet to hear where the matter came from that allowed evolution. No matter how far back scientists explain our beginnings, the question of where things come from still stands. I.e. with God out of the question, am I being asked to believe that, at one point something came out of nothing of it's own accord?
If I'm against picketing, how do I show it?

Offline MS1COYS

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 820
  • Alfie 'H' 10-09-11
Re: Any anti-theists in the house?
« Reply #22 on: 15 October 2012, 01:23 »
And for what it's worth, I have yet to hear where the matter came from that allowed evolution. No matter how far back scientists explain our beginnings, the question of where things come from still stands. I.e. with God out of the question, am I being asked to believe that, at one point something came out of nothing of it's own accord?

Here's a link directly related to your comment of 'where matter came from that allowed evolution'. Skip to 1 minute 10 seconds to hear an answer that makes sense to a 'thinking person'. - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3xeK7R-TgHI

What is more likely. That the whole natural order of the world is suspended or that a Jewish woman told a lie? (David Hume)

"The theory of (a deistic) creation is essentially a refusal to think back beyond a certain time in the past when it becomes difficult to follow the chain of causation. To hold such a belief is, therefore, always an excuse for intellectual laziness, and generally a sign of it." - JBS Haldane

Scientists are at least trying to validate their findings (somethings which Christians do not adopt and follow principally on 'blind faith')

I mean do you agree that the earth is 13.77 billion years old or do you believe that it is between 6,000-12,000 years old?

Do you believe that it would be possible for instance to find the fossil of a rabbit from the Precambrian era?

Are 'Atheists/Non believers' expected to believe that 'God' flung the stars out into the sky?
 
That God placed Adam and Eve on this planet as the first humans and we've evolved from there and that humans have not evolved from Chimpanzee's?
 
That Noah built an ark that was able to capacitate 7 (male/female) pairs of every 'clean' animal and 7 (male/female) pairs of every bird and 2 (male/female) pairs of every 'unclean' animal and bird specie as suggested in Genesis 7:2–3 and that God shut the door before Dinosaurs, Kangaroos and Penguins had a chance to hop aboard?

Would it not be acceptable to expect that if God did create the planet as Christians believe, that he would have at least mentioned it was of spherical form?

Why for example, did the 'Ten Commandments' not include, child molestation, rape, slavery, human trafficking etc. Could it be that this was because all of this was endorsed in the beginning by the Bible?

As Hitchens says, why did 'God/Heaven' wait for 98,000 years witnessing all that went before it in that time, famine, struggle, vision less war, people dying of their teeth, before suddenly deciding 2,000 years ago 'enough is enough' and the best way to intervene is to condemn someone to a human sacrifice (Jesus, the son of God), in the less literate parts of the Middle East, when for example 'God/Heaven' could have appealed to the Chinese for example, where people could read, write, study evidence and where there was civilisation, rather than a desert, where there was nothing? After all it was Jesus' own people, the Jews who crucified him, because they were non-believers.....

I think the most preposterous incinuation of all, is that our whole futures are pre-determined. That our destiny is out of our hands, everything that goes before us was pre-supposed and determined by God and we have nothing to do with it and that we are 'dead' until we become 'believers' and that we can only live by accepting an absolute authority?

You are entitled to believe whatever you wish to believe my friend, that is your choice. But the subject of this thread is Anti-Theism not Mono-Theism. You obviously believe you have an argument against and I would thrive on a debate, but.....

“What can be asserted without proof can be dismissed without proof.” - Hitch






« Last Edit: 15 October 2012, 15:13 by MS1COYS »
Evolution Map / Longlife USA 80mm TBE w/100 cell Sports Cat / ITG Maxogen G60 / Forge Twintercooler/ Forge TB Hose / R8 Coilpacks / EBC D&G Front & Rear Discs / EBC Yellowstuff Pads / BSH PCV Kit / Poly Pro Front & Rear / W.A.L.K / APR Torque Arm / 034Motorsport Density Line Engine Mounts / Vibratechnics Subframe Mount / Vibratechnics Dogbone Bush

292bhp / 287lbft

Gavv8

  • Guest
Re: Any anti-theists in the house?
« Reply #23 on: 15 October 2012, 05:59 »
Just for the record it was Peter Hitchens debating Russel Brand and he is a born again christian.

Offline MS1COYS

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 820
  • Alfie 'H' 10-09-11
Re: Any anti-theists in the house?
« Reply #24 on: 15 October 2012, 08:49 »
Just for the record it was Peter Hitchens debating Russel Brand and he is a born again christian.

Who are you reaffirming that to Gavv? Are you implying that Skred believes the wrong Hitchen brother is a born again Christian?
« Last Edit: 15 October 2012, 08:56 by MS1COYS »
Evolution Map / Longlife USA 80mm TBE w/100 cell Sports Cat / ITG Maxogen G60 / Forge Twintercooler/ Forge TB Hose / R8 Coilpacks / EBC D&G Front & Rear Discs / EBC Yellowstuff Pads / BSH PCV Kit / Poly Pro Front & Rear / W.A.L.K / APR Torque Arm / 034Motorsport Density Line Engine Mounts / Vibratechnics Subframe Mount / Vibratechnics Dogbone Bush

292bhp / 287lbft

Offline R32UK

  • Forum addict
  • *
  • Posts: 5,683
Re: Any anti-theists in the house?
« Reply #25 on: 15 October 2012, 10:32 »
Lets say.. for arguments sake, that there was conclusive proof of god and religion and in this case chiristianity. How would this effect you?

Offline MS1COYS

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 820
  • Alfie 'H' 10-09-11
Re: Any anti-theists in the house?
« Reply #26 on: 15 October 2012, 12:09 »
Lets say.. for arguments sake, that there was conclusive proof of god and religion and in this case chiristianity. How would this effect you?

Well obviously it would destroy my whole belief system and ethos of thinking, that much should be obvious. But it's not true so I'm well and truly safe on that front.
Why R32UK are you about to announce the 'second coming'.
To satisfy your question entirely, the whole ethos behind Christianity, is you must repent your sins before you die, otherwise you will not be granted entry to 'heaven'. So what do you think I would do...... #lastchancesaloon

Now let's turn your comment on it's head!
What would happen if there was conclusive proof that no God existed, there was no heaven and no hell and 'god forbid'  :grin: evolution did actually exist?
What would that do Christianity, in fact, to religion as a whole? It would certainly do far more damage! Inextricably so in fact, because it would probably be the end of the world as we know it!

Here's another link, that maybe of interest. - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3xeK7R-TgHI

I will also post this link in my previous post directed at Skred, just so it can help answer his question in respect of where the 'matter came from that allowed evolution'....... Skip to 1 minute 10 seconds if you want an answer to your question.
Evolution Map / Longlife USA 80mm TBE w/100 cell Sports Cat / ITG Maxogen G60 / Forge Twintercooler/ Forge TB Hose / R8 Coilpacks / EBC D&G Front & Rear Discs / EBC Yellowstuff Pads / BSH PCV Kit / Poly Pro Front & Rear / W.A.L.K / APR Torque Arm / 034Motorsport Density Line Engine Mounts / Vibratechnics Subframe Mount / Vibratechnics Dogbone Bush

292bhp / 287lbft

Offline R32UK

  • Forum addict
  • *
  • Posts: 5,683
Re: Any anti-theists in the house?
« Reply #27 on: 15 October 2012, 13:11 »
I dont think it would change me... although it would take much more courage to 'do right' for more people I guess.

Would the world be a better place without religion... im not sure it would. I dont believe any religion promotes hate, violence and murder against other religions. Just those that seek solace in something to justify their crazy ways.

Everyone likes to think that 'they are better' be it location, hair colour, football team or religion. Religious folk tend to have a air of superiority about them... this does little to justify their cause.


I also think sometimes you need to look at many religions differently... many come with storys, tales, if you like which become the point of focus. The focus needs to be on the message.... not its means of delivery.

As we all know a story told a 100 times is going to be very different from the original story.... but as long as the message remains unchanged.

I guess it boils down to one thing and one thing only.... FAITH. You either got it, or you dont!

Offline MS1COYS

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 820
  • Alfie 'H' 10-09-11
Re: Any anti-theists in the house?
« Reply #28 on: 15 October 2012, 13:47 »
I don't believe any religion promotes hate, violence and murder against other religions.

I don't want to come across as rude, but it seems to be the case, that you have either wrongly worded this statement or you are unaware of religious war crimes that have been committed over the last 1000 years.
 
From the 'first crusade' some 1000 years ago by the Roman Catholics to eradicate the Muslim settlers by way of mass genocide and regain the supposed holy land of Jerusalem to the 'second crusade' some 50 years later, also committed by the Roman Catholics, principally Pope Eugene III.....(luckily second time round the Turks defended their settlement and the planned mass atrocities did not come to fruition.)

In today's world we have the raging war between extreme Christians and Muslims, that is currently wiping out hundreds and thousands of lives in the middle east and please let's not forget also that George Bush Snr and Jnr are both Episcopalian Catholics and Tony Blair is a Roman Catholic, these three men are mostly to blame for leading us to war against the Islamic extremist, but fundamentally the Muslim community abroad, by declaring it a 'war on terror' in Iraq and Afghanistan.

I'm not even going to go into the Israel/Palestine divide.......

Please don't let my statements incinuate that religion is incapable of 'doing good', of course it does.

« Last Edit: 15 October 2012, 13:50 by MS1COYS »
Evolution Map / Longlife USA 80mm TBE w/100 cell Sports Cat / ITG Maxogen G60 / Forge Twintercooler/ Forge TB Hose / R8 Coilpacks / EBC D&G Front & Rear Discs / EBC Yellowstuff Pads / BSH PCV Kit / Poly Pro Front & Rear / W.A.L.K / APR Torque Arm / 034Motorsport Density Line Engine Mounts / Vibratechnics Subframe Mount / Vibratechnics Dogbone Bush

292bhp / 287lbft

Offline VR6_Wherry

  • Forum addict
  • *
  • Posts: 4,940
Re: Any anti-theists in the house?
« Reply #29 on: 15 October 2012, 14:05 »
I think for once i am really enjoying your posts MS1COYS :grin: :kiss: