To b honest I haven't driven either just a mk3 vr6. Got mk4 1.8t and they are heavy lol which is a shame 
Looking forward to seeing the outcome. Ur car sounds like a beast as does Toby's 
Loving some of the cars on here 
Same fella I've not driven a mk4 1.8t, only been shotgun. Todys mk4 looks tidy and the power delivery is excellent and it's very different to mine!
I wouldn't call mine a beast but it's fairly quick, just tweaks to improve the performance. The same as you fella!
There are some sick cars on here.