Author Topic: SHOCKED! a formal article of hatred for the mk2, comparing to an Allegro!! why  (Read 3585 times)

Offline andykram

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 726
My first Golf Gti, a Mk3 which I got in the 90s on an R plate was fat when I look back at it. I remember test driving it against a hot 306 at the time and picked it because it was a VW, even though the 306 was quicker to drive, faster and cheaper. Yes, it was fat, lumpy and never a Gti in a million years but I loved it.
The fattest were the Mk4s. I had two. They were shockingly unreliable and put me off VW until the Mk6 GTi I now have came out. That's an awesome piece of kit. And it dwarfs the Mk2 when I park them side by side.
So to accuse the Mk2 of being fat is a bit stupid in my book. Wasn't the Allegro in fact a round, dumpy thing whose only unique feature was a square steering wheel?

VW BUSH

  • Guest
lol i had an Allegro and it was the least rusty car ive owned, no these cars had the worst built engine and drive system in the world ever.
You had the A series engine up to 1.3 and then you got the Maxi engine from 1.5 to 1.7.
The mini engine could not haul the weight around and broke gearboxes and shafts like butter, even more so when you run the hydrospastic suspension low to look cool :lipsrsealed: or if it just leaked out overnight on your drive.
The E series engine was just as pants, they did go up to a 2.2 straight 6 which was muchos pantos as well.
You could however fit any "upspec" BMC parts with little bother like four pots, MG wheels, Turbo engines etc etc, but these were made of cheese too.

My leggy had twin headlamps, chin spoiler, Princess brakes, MG wheels, slammed on its arse either through stupidity or a leaking "shock" and all the power you could get from a 1275 A series without blowing the head on a steep hill :grin:
(very difficult car to push due to the shape of the rear)
I was getting 13mpg from it so sold it for a 240GLT Auto which got about 25mpg and was cheaper to insure.
I had fun in my leggy but it was in no way as good a Mk2 or even a ford fiesta.
I do think the Mk1 is the best out of the bunch so far as original concept and design, with the low point being the Mk4. But even the worst golf is a streets ahead of any "British" cars they competed with

Offline Gti_Jamo

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,113
  • 1991 Corrado 1.8 G60
Its just someones personal opinion with nothing really to back up there critisism. I'm a fan of some BL cars but they made a lot of rubbish over the years. Not a patch on vw build quality over the entire spectrum.


97' Mk3 Golf Gti 2.0 8v Rebuild Project http://www.golfgtiforum.co.uk/index.php?topic=208865.0

Offline Hurdy

  • Serious forum addict
  • *
  • Posts: 8,466
Its just someones personal opinion with nothing really to back up there critisism.

My dad had a lot of BL cars and I ended up using either a bus or a pick up lorry A LOT!!! :grin:
So in my case I have plenty of back up!  :laugh:
Seat Leon Cupra Black 290 DSG

VW BUSH

  • Guest
Most of the good "BL" cars were from smaller companies that they bought up and soon ruined.
Early German cars were utter tat as well, the Beatle is iconic but piss poor in reality but by the early 70's the "that'll do" quality control policey was abandoned for something more robust, i dont think Rover started this untill the 90's as the Jap "Rovers" were so much better right up to the BMW buy up (and far too late to save them it turns out)

Cars are much better built now as they are so expensive to buy/run, you would not buy something like a Dolomite and be happy these days :grin:

Offline cняis

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 3,034
  • Know there's something burning over there...
BL never made a good car, they had a few good ideas  to be fair  but allways managed to cock them up royaly usally with really shonkey build quality.  and the cars were sat around that long in between strikes they were allready rusty before leaveing the factory

Trouble was their "that'll do" attitude. Everything they produced was second best.


I don't think a semi will give the same results

Offline richw911

  • 10k hero
  • *
  • Posts: 18,673
  • The Linkmeister and an OEM Freak.
Agree with everyone that's just rubbish  :laugh: The MK2 Golf is in  a different league to ANY BL car  :grin:

As said BL were very rusty, poorly designed, unreliable,cheap and nasty!   

 That said you cant beat a classic Mini to put smile on your face  :laugh: I absolutely love mine  :smiley:

As said rusty when they left the factory, they used to bend the doors to fit, nothing fits properly  :grin: But everyone should have a go in one at least once brilliant fun  :cool:

I do think that all modern cars are dull to look at though - don't get me wrong amazing machines I couldn't do without a modern car for everyday use!

You just don't get a buzz that you used to get when cars had individuality - Real character , chrome bright work, , lightweight, no electronics to help you "drive" power steering brakes etc  (No fault codes)  :laugh:, Manual choke, engines made by the manufacturer (Not borrowed from another make) No plastic dashboards etc etc

 Most of all you used to be a part of the car not being taken for a ride like modern cars make you feel All IMO of course  :smiley: 


MKIV Mod Squad™ a part of the headlight police.

Offline JC

  • 10k hero
  • *
  • Posts: 13,429
  • Back in the North.
Agree with everyone that's just rubbish  :laugh: The MK2 Golf is in  a different league to ANY BL car  :grin:


minus 1  :lipsrsealed:

They made some real  beauties. . . . . . .

Offline Andy!

  • I live here
  • *****
  • Posts: 741
  • VR6
Has a downside though.  Its quite hard to spot in a carpark.

 :grin:

Truth.

Offline Mortimer Hill

  • Not said much yet
  • **
  • Posts: 98
I came accross this link on google and i was shocked but ended up reading the whole thing.

http://www.aronline.co.uk/blogs/2011/08/08/overhyped-and-over-here-volkswagen-golf-mk2/

Not only a turd polishers site, but very, very  anti German, to the extent of trying to claim big Renaults were better than BMWs/ Mercs/ Audis  :(