correct you cant compare a turbo s3 lump to a vr6 n/a,but turbo the vr and its a different story my money would be on the 6 pot all day long
have you been in either ?? well shut up then LOL
Mine isn't standard no more. and i would say the turbo Vr would have a hard time trying to beat mine.. next year see's a bigger turbo too and 350+ BHP with LSD...
Well no I have not been in a golf with an s3 engine but the wife had a tt 225 and It was nippy but I think the 1.8 bam engine is weak and I have been in a supercharged vr that would of smoked your golf no problem so there you go you can shut up you don't like it when people talk about anything other than the 1.8t it ain't all that that's why it was dropped for the better 2.0t
the 1.8T engine is just so easy to get big power from...
you are such a clueless goon, can't even quote correctly let alone give a valid reply

A standard S3, or TT does feel sh!t, numb and boring.. also don't feel fast.. i know this...i really do..
now you take that engine, which is not weak like you say it is you numpty, modify it and wack it into a MK3 and believe me you have a serious weapon on your hands..mine is not even fully custom mapped yet and is still only on it's K04 turbo and it matches pace with my mates R32 SC easily...
Now all this ball bags about this VR SC you have been in FFS, phaaa, id put my V5 down on that one. i know a guy who has one, he is on ED38 and he has the biggest SC on any VR6 in the UK... well one of 2 cars actually and you know what. he only has 220ibft!! even he says my car would smoke his.. you don't even know the specs on my car to even say what would smoke it and what wouldn't and TBH id not be right bothered about what is faster.. my car is very fast and lots of fun. it makes me smile every time i put the foot down and thats good enough for me..
not a fan of superchargers, too much pointless noise. Wack a turbo on a VR and it will be very similar to mine, but use a load more fuel.. and will never be as easy to get even more power from than what the S3 lump will be.. Have you not seen some of the BIG turbo kits you can get for this very highly tuneable engine? why do you think everyone wants to use the AMK / BAM engines ?? ?
lastly the reason they replaced the engine with the 2.0 FSI was mainly about emissions..
Regarding weight of the engines. A VR engine is heavier than the 1.8T, a guy on Vortex weighed one, the VR block minus head weigh in a 145KG, the 1.8T is between 80kg - 100kg with head