Hmmmm,
When I was growing up the MK2 was at its peak!! I loved it but then when I passed my test the MK3 was about although at the time people always said to MK2 was better, but the VR6 kicked ass.
Then the MK4 came out and it was my first Golf. Great car but when my company car came along I had to sell it and had some spare cash. It was then a toss up between the MK1 2 and 3... After speaking to a MK1 enthusiast I decided to try and find one but there were hardly any decent ones around for less than £1500.
Thats when I found my MK2 16 valver... £700 and it is awesome for handling.

So... its not a question of whats the better car, just what do people prefer???