Samyang 8mm or Sigma 10-20

[T_J_G]

Been shooting a lot of stuff 70mm plus, but realised I loved shooting wide angle. So I'm tempted to invest in one of the above, will be on a crop sensor on my 1000d. I think the 8mm may be too wide and also is a fixed length, whereas the Sigma may give more options.

[Diamond Hell]

One's fish-eye, t'other's just wide-angle.

Which do you want?

[T_J_G]

Both

I guess what I really want is a wide angle.

[Diamond Hell]

I think you'll be able to do an awful lot more with the 10-20mm lens.

Unless you're planning to shoot a lot of skateboard photography. 

[shepgti]

my kit is crying out for a 10-20mm lens!

[Ridg]

for you 10-20

[DubFan]

The 10-20 is much more versatile, you'll find yourself using it much more than a fisheye.
I sometimes want something wider than the 18mm on my kit lens but can't justify (yet) the cost of a 10-20, especially when there are other lenses I'd rather have.

[Diamond Hell]

I have pretty much not used my 18-55 kit lens since I bought the 10-20.

Just get a bit closer. 

And for landscapes, it's unbeatable.

[T_J_G]

Since I've got the 70-200 and the 50mm my kit lens doesn't get much of a look in.

Really fancy something like the Sigma.

[T_J_G]

Given the new competition subject I need to invest and quickly!