I'm in 2 minds about the wheels, my head says they shouldn't work but I think they will probably look awesome when on! 
I felt exactly the same way. When I put one next to the wheel, I wasn't too sure at first, but it is growing on me. I know I like them on Mk4's- have seen a couple on here, but I think cus my car is like a metallic and the black on the wheels in straight black it doesn't merge as much as I wanted. I think I need to get the tyres on and then see

might take the car for a full respray to sort this niggling feeling out
