I can't speak for an 8v, but on a vr6 it makes a huge difference.
I had an induction kit on the vr, it was great apart from there was a horrible whistling noise between 2000 and 3000 rpm.
I put a standard air box back in with a standard filter, and the engine was so flat, no power until over 4000 rpm.
I drilled the box wing side, and removed the trumpet, put a k&n panel in, and bloody hell what a difference.
The pick up is amazing, just to emphasise the point, with a k&n on it, the traction control cuts in 1st gear, if i really hammer it (i've got sh!t cheap front tyres), this didn't happen at all with a standard airbox.
I'd like to see the so called internet 'experts' that reckon filters just make a noise explain that one.