I had a bad experience with a prevous car (Scooby) where I had 2 attempted break ins. Thankfully they didnt do too much damage. Even though they didnt get away with the car it made me really paranoid and so I sold the car.
To answer your question, I don't think I would want it back. But I guess if the cops find it you have to have it back. In my case they came back and had another go at the house, so it would make me think about wanting to keep the car. It worth bolstering up the security on your property if you can. I put some extra high fence panels in and a few security lights.