This weeks Autocar

[Hurdy]

If they make a MKVI Golf GTI Edition35, then I MAY think about getting one......Maybe!

IF...

It has at least 400+bhp capability on the stock turbo

Otherwise it would be too slow for me

[luvmygti]

I saw a golf R at the weekend for the first time, it was nicer than the mk6 gti but if i wer looking for that sort of motor i'd go for a S3.

is that just because the s3 is cheaper? or because you want the old model with a new a3 shape due out??

I just prefer the S3 to the R.

I didnt know the S3 was cheeper but now i do, i prefer it even more  

[R32UK]

Golf R with the MK5 engine you mean? . . .

Suprised this still going lol

only because it was the cheap option 

[R32UK]

I saw a golf R at the weekend for the first time, it was nicer than the mk6 gti but if i wer looking for that sort of motor i'd go for a S3.

is that just because the s3 is cheaper? or because you want the old model with a new a3 shape due out??

I just prefer the S3 to the R.

I didnt know the S3 was cheeper but now i do, i prefer it even more  

If you prefer the look of the audi then you should get one... just as cheapas the mk5 now

[am1w]

If you prefer the look of the audi then you should get one... just as cheapas the mk5 now

.... and just as out-of-date!

[R32UK]

If they make a MKVI Golf GTI Edition35, then I MAY think about getting one......Maybe!

IF...

It has at least 400+bhp capability on the stock turbo

Otherwise it would be too slow for me

I thought the the golf R has he same turbo as the ed30? pretty much the same as an s3 in a golf body... i would have thought 400bhp wouldnt not be a problem, with the added benifit of AWD also.

[AlanD]

Yes, the Golf R does indeed have the same turbo (and engine) as the ED30 but Hurdy was talking about a so called 35th edition which will happen I would have thought (a 25th and 30th have both been made, theres also an Anni MK3 which at a guess is a 20th edition?).

[luvmygti]

I saw a golf R at the weekend for the first time, it was nicer than the mk6 gti but if i wer looking for that sort of motor i'd go for a S3.

is that just because the s3 is cheaper? or because you want the old model with a new a3 shape due out??

I just prefer the S3 to the R.

I didnt know the S3 was cheeper but now i do, i prefer it even more  

If you prefer the look of the audi then you should get one... just as cheapas the mk5 now

Lol, i prefer the S3 to the mk6, NOT the nicer mk5 

[R32UK]

I saw a golf R at the weekend for the first time, it was nicer than the mk6 gti but if i wer looking for that sort of motor i'd go for a S3.

is that just because the s3 is cheaper? or because you want the old model with a new a3 shape due out??

I just prefer the S3 to the R.

I didnt know the S3 was cheeper but now i do, i prefer it even more  

If you prefer the look of the audi then you should get one... just as cheapas the mk5 now

Lol, i prefer the S3 to the mk6, NOT the nicer mk5 

You can lead a fool to water..... 

[AlanD]

But you cant teach him to swim? lol