in order to prolong the thread....
i've driven the new S4 - fantastic car for the money. But M3, RS4, S4.. are a different type of car to the Cayman S, well i suppose you could say similiar to the GTI. Besides i ain't got any family so don't need the seats.
Having said that, was in the beamer garage the other day - > M3 Alpine (white)... looked the biz, very impressive piece of kit.
i only want to spend 23k(ish), was thinking boxster as not sure what cayman you'd get for that money...