As i said in the mk6 section
For me the Golf R will have to be a hell of a lot better to drive than the S3 to justify the larger price (~£4K(You can get S3s new for £25K), the R has a much lower equipment spec as standard and lower badge than the S3, and i just cannot see it from previous drives of haldex equipped cars for it to be that much different to drive. I wait and see, but i think people who are ordering before even trying it are simply barmy.