id actually replace the cap itself
i got one from GSF about 6mths ago and still found myself to be losing water, even though there is no sign watsover of any headgasket probs, then i listened to the expansion cap last night after i got home from work - and you could hear it his
so today i went to VAG and got a proper cap, only cost ?5.80, and you can see the difference in quality between the VAG item and GSF sh!te item!