i want a gearbox to do two things, change gears when i want to, and change them quickly. you don't get this with dsg.
That is in fact the definition of exactly what DSG does. Couldn't have put it better myself. 
unless the dsg in the golf is different from that in the eos, i really didn't feel that way at all. etto.
Was the Eos DSG the new 7 speed, or was it the current 6 speed?

And anyway, even if it was the same 6-speed DSG as found in our GTIs, it can still have very different software on it. If you don't believe me, try a current GTI with DSG, and then try a Golf5 TDI with the same DSG - and the change patterns will be very different.
