GolfGTIforum.co.uk

Model specific boards => Golf mk4 => Topic started by: efunc on 26 April 2013, 00:24

Title: Help: Clutch not working in forward gears, only in reverse
Post by: efunc on 26 April 2013, 00:24
Hi all, I'm looking for a quick diagnosis as I was stranded tonight and had to get Kartec to tow me home. My clutch went at the lights. I can get in all the gears fine, but it's not biting. The only gear that I can only move in is reverse. I haven't actually tried 2, 3, 4, 5 or 6 though - only 1 and reverse.
 
The car is a 1.9 GT TDI (PD115) and it's unmapped. I've been happily driving on the original clutch and gearbox for 130,000 miles, and would be happy with standard replacement. But what does it sound like has actually failed?
Title: Re: Help: Clutch not working in forward gears, only in reverse
Post by: mcgee9t2 on 26 April 2013, 12:48
IMO I think it may be gear box, if it was clutch surely it wouldnt work in reverse aswell as forward?

could be first gears gone. ide try second see if it bites, if so you have your problem.
Title: Re: Help: Clutch not working in forward gears, only in reverse
Post by: efunc on 26 April 2013, 12:55
Thanks. What I found is that 3, 4, 5, 6 and reverse work, but just no 1st and 2nd. I just put it into 5th just now and raised the clutch, took off the handbrake and seemed to roll off under power (down a slight slope). So it's not slipping. Or should it have stalled? What do you think?
Title: Re: Help: Clutch not working in forward gears, only in reverse
Post by: mcgee9t2 on 26 April 2013, 18:42
Thanks. What I found is that 3, 4, 5, 6 and reverse work, but just no 1st and 2nd. I just put it into 5th just now and raised the clutch, took off the handbrake and seemed to roll off under power (down a slight slope). So it's not slipping. Or should it have stalled? What do you think?
no mechanic but by the sounds of it to me 1st and 2nd has gone. not sure what the arrangement in the box is, 1 gear could have gone then debris from this taken out the other gear?
Title: Re: Help: Clutch not working in forward gears, only in reverse
Post by: topher on 26 April 2013, 19:12
check simple stuff first, are the selector cables still attached?
Title: Re: Help: Clutch not working in forward gears, only in reverse
Post by: Turbo_T on 26 April 2013, 21:50
when u put it in 5th did u just take foot of clutch or did u try pulling off like normal in 1st ?
Title: Re: Help: Clutch not working in forward gears, only in reverse
Post by: efunc on 27 April 2013, 00:30
when u put it in 5th did u just take foot of clutch or did u try pulling off like normal in 1st ?
I got it at biting point, then eased off the clutch gently whilst releasing the handbrake. Seemed to start edging forward, but then it was pointing down a slope. Why?
Title: Re: Help: Clutch not working in forward gears, only in reverse
Post by: efunc on 27 April 2013, 00:33
check simple stuff first, are the selector cables still attached?
Thanks, that's a useful tip. I'm not in a great place to check this now because it's dumped in the street. If I jack it up will it be obvious to an idiot like me?
Title: Re: Help: Clutch not working in forward gears, only in reverse
Post by: efunc on 29 April 2013, 01:10
Well, all the cables and everything are fine. It's almost definitely the selector fork, so it'll be a gearbox out and refurb job :(

Anyone know what I should be looking at in terms of cost? and any recommended companies around London?
Title: Re: Help: Clutch not working in forward gears, only in reverse
Post by: mar_k on 04 May 2013, 11:25
Where abouts in London are you?
Title: Re: Help: Clutch not working in forward gears, only in reverse
Post by: efunc on 04 May 2013, 11:28
Harrow, Middlesex.
Title: Re: Help: Clutch not working in forward gears, only in reverse
Post by: mar_k on 04 May 2013, 11:37
Harrow, Middlesex.




There not that local to you but they are good.


02083096200


They will have what you need.

Do you plan to remove and fit your self?
Title: Re: Help: Clutch not working in forward gears, only in reverse
Post by: efunc on 04 May 2013, 11:42
volkswagenspares right? spoke to them already. yes, they can remove and fix my box for about £1000. I'm after someone to do it for less and thinking about diamond transmission in park royal. might see them on tuesday. cheers.
Title: Re: Help: Clutch not working in forward gears, only in reverse
Post by: efunc on 21 May 2013, 01:06
All sorted now. Got the gearbox fixed for £660 and fitted a clutch too for £420 locally.  :cry:
Title: Re: Help: Clutch not working in forward gears, only in reverse
Post by: barrym381 on 21 May 2013, 01:09
All sorted now. Got the gearbox fixed for £660 and fitted a clutch too for £420 locally.  :cry:
:shocked: thats expensive
Title: Re: Help: Clutch not working in forward gears, only in reverse
Post by: efunc on 21 May 2013, 01:25
It's actually the cheapest I could find. Most wanted about £8-900 just to look at the gearbox :(
Title: Re: Help: Clutch not working in forward gears, only in reverse
Post by: mcgee9t2 on 21 May 2013, 10:30
ouch... what was it then? selector?