GolfGTIforum.co.uk

General => The garage => Topic started by: Horney on 21 December 2011, 13:06

Title: BAM/20vT issue and question
Post by: Horney on 21 December 2011, 13:06

Hi Guys,

A mate at work has a BAM powered S3 and it's suffering cutting out. He took it to Audi and they have said it needs a new cam sensor which will cost £1800 fitted as it's an engine out job!!!!!!

Anyone know what this is likely to be? I've advised him to take it to a local specialist I know for a 2nd opinion as this sounds bonkers!

Nick

Title: Re: BAM/20vT issue and question
Post by: johnnyvr6 on 21 December 2011, 13:17

lol 1800 thats audi trying to pull his pants down tell him to get a vag com to read the codes

Title: Re: BAM/20vT issue and question
Post by: Rhyso on 21 December 2011, 13:44

Cam positioning sensor by any chance??

Think for the bog standard 1.8T's they are like £30-£40!!  And they aren't an engine out job!

Drop Topher a PM as he'll know for sure :afro:

Title: Re: BAM/20vT issue and question
Post by: topher on 21 December 2011, 16:54

cam sensor takes 10 minutes to change, but i dont think that would cause the car to cut out. The crank sensor would.. and that takes a bit longer than 10 minutes to change. Maybe 15 :grin:

Title: Re: BAM/20vT issue and question
Post by: barrym381 on 21 December 2011, 17:21

Quote from: topher on 21 December 2011, 16:54

cam sensor takes 10 minutes to change, but i dont think that would cause the car to cut out. The crank sensor would.. and that takes a bit longer than 10 minutes to change. Maybe 15 :grin:

would the crank sensor cause it to cut out only when warm  :smiley:

Title: Re: BAM/20vT issue and question
Post by: topher on 21 December 2011, 18:01

not always. An early tell-tale of it failing though can be difficulty starting the engine while warm

Title: Re: BAM/20vT issue and question
Post by: danny_p on 22 December 2011, 00:39

id say more likely cranck sensor,  read the codes.


its actulay quite amazing how hard it is to stop an engine running by unplugging stuff they'll run with pritty much anyting bar the carnck sensor unplugged

Title: Re: BAM/20vT issue and question
Post by: lemski on 22 December 2011, 08:31

We've had a car in that wouldn't run when warm because of the cam sensor. It was a hyundi though. Best to scan it for the codes

Title: Re: BAM/20vT issue and question
Post by: Horney on 22 December 2011, 10:24

Right I've seen the paperwork from Audi and it states speed sensor needs replacing AND camshaft adjuster has failed. It's the camshaft adjuster that is £1800 to replace and that's with a 20% discount on the labour!!!!!!!

nick

Title: Re: BAM/20vT issue and question
Post by: topher on 22 December 2011, 16:45

engine still wouldn't need to come out. second opinion definitely needed there..

Title: Re: BAM/20vT issue and question
Post by: danny_p on 22 December 2011, 18:35

i'm trying to work out why they would even say that.  the cam adjusters on the head and the cranck sensors behind the oil filter