GolfGTIforum.co.uk

Model specific boards => Golf mk2 => Topic started by: andynorfolk on 09 June 2011, 17:53

Title: which panel filter?
Post by: andynorfolk on 09 June 2011, 17:53
i need a new air box as mine was butchered when i got it and the muppet actually drilled holes in the top of the airbox as well as the bottom :S

so im gonna upgrade the filter too... i have used pipercross panel filters in the past and have always been good, anyone else got any suggestions? i've always though k&n was just a name to sell cheap rubbish under...
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: AudiA8Quattro on 09 June 2011, 17:55
I've always used k&n.
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: andynorfolk on 09 June 2011, 18:02
i had a k&n induction kit on my bravo 1.6 and it just did nothing... so then i ran a pipercross filter in the standard airbox and it seemed to run infinitely better
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: jmsheahan on 09 June 2011, 18:26
Just put a standard one from VWS in there. Fiver. Job done.
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: mk2bal on 09 June 2011, 18:31
As above. If 16v, drilled front corner, snorkel removed, wing blanking trim removed,  £5 vws filter. In winter I run no snorkel at all jus a great big hole out front, in summer I run some convoluted cable duct attached to front of snorkel as cold air duct, but the snorkel itself is chopped off inside so I still get the noise with only a few less db's.
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: Sam on 09 June 2011, 18:37
Standard is best  :smiley:
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: andynorfolk on 09 June 2011, 18:43
i want the airbox kept completely standard, but the standard paper filters are let's be honest fairly crappy and you need to keep replacing them...

reckon i might just go with a pipercross panel filter
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: Wayne on 09 June 2011, 20:56
K & N is a good choice.
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: The Mighty Elvi on 09 June 2011, 21:42
It's an air filter FFS.  Save your money and get a standard one.

Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: dubber36 on 09 June 2011, 21:50
It's an air filter FFS.  Save your money and get a standard one.



How true.
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: tech1889 on 10 June 2011, 00:21
KnN or pipercross will be fine.. and lets face it they have a lifetime guarantee which standard ones dont.. even if it makes no difference i prefer them... my mk2 when finished im gona run a custom induction kit..
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: mk2bal on 10 June 2011, 11:02
Ur mk2's gonna have a £10k total bill isn't it?! I'd 20vt it for the aggro and expense you're going to,that abf will prob bore you soon enough!!
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: tech1889 on 10 June 2011, 11:32
^^ someone's a happy soul today aren't they... I gave my opinion sorry if it's not the same as yours.. Yer my mk2 may cost me 10k and ?? It's a second car for me and I enjoy working on it slowly..
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: mk2bal on 10 June 2011, 12:58
Sorry mate wasn't being funny!! It can sound dodgey in text form, wasn't the context I meant it in, I'm jus sayin jesus its no expense spared!! Wasn't being funny soz!!
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: tech1889 on 10 June 2011, 13:19
Lol no worries mate.
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: Diamond Hell on 10 June 2011, 15:19
Get a standard one and change regularly. 

Better filtration and probably higher flow than a wash and re-use one.

Especially after the K&N/Pipercross unit's  been washed a few time.
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: emery1990 on 10 June 2011, 18:02
If you have a 16v airbox, you can have my k an n panel filter for a 5er and what ever postage is on top.
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: Ade244 on 21 June 2011, 21:32
haha stick it on ebay, I'm after one also - you may get a tenner :rolleyes:

I tend to stick with k&n's on bikes and cars just because I'm used to giving them a clean at service time.
Get the big recharge kit and it lasts for years. Been using them for over 20 years now never had any probs.
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: AudiA8Quattro on 21 June 2011, 21:50
Paper filters are good and flow well, but only when new. The flow rates quickly drop.
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: andynorfolk on 21 June 2011, 21:54
got a pipercross one, along with a new unbutchered air box :D

cause apparently when drlling the airbox they thought it'd be good to drill the top too so unfiltered air was being drawn straight into the throttle body...

GENIUS!  :huh:
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: tech1889 on 21 June 2011, 23:49
got a pipercross one, along with a new unbutchered air box :D

cause apparently when drlling the airbox they thought it'd be good to drill the top too so unfiltered air was being drawn straight into the throttle body...

GENIUS!  :huh:

good engineering knowledge i guess  :grin:
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: andynorfolk on 22 June 2011, 00:10
Quote
good engineering knowledge i guess  :grin:

;)
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: Sam on 22 June 2011, 01:39
got a pipercross one, along with a new unbutchered air box :D

cause apparently when drlling the airbox they thought it'd be good to drill the top too so unfiltered air was being drawn straight into the throttle body...

GENIUS!  :huh:

good engineering knowledge i guess  :grin:

Yeh, I taught him everything I know
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: delirical on 23 June 2011, 14:16
A friend of mine took the plastic cone part out of my airbox and now at cruising speed i have a very annoying droaning noise a bit like.. warb warb warb warb... i'm sure its because of what he has done.. he threw the bits away  :evil: anyone else experienced this?

Anyone got a airbox for a g60 or golf if they are the same?? i dont like the noise  :sad:
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: rob.043 on 23 June 2011, 15:17
got a trumpet for a digi 8v box, if it'll fit its yours.
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: andynorfolk on 23 June 2011, 19:40
oops... i just cut the cone out in the new one i got as it looks like all it's doing is restricting the air flow... was that a stupid thing to do?  :undecided:
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: rob.043 on 24 June 2011, 09:11
the cone/trumpet should pull out without breaking (so can be replaced if you prefer it), depending how you go about it!  It is there to reduce noise primarily, and will have an effect on restricting flow.
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: delirical on 24 June 2011, 11:15
oops... i just cut the cone out in the new one i got as it looks like all it's doing is restricting the air flow... was that a stupid thing to do?  :undecided:

Let me know if you get a bloody annoying droaning noise when cruising.. tunes have to be turned up to cancel it out, actually gives me a headache!
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: delirical on 24 June 2011, 11:16
got a trumpet for a digi 8v box, if it'll fit its yours.

That would be awesome mate, apart from your in scotland... can you find out how much postage would be, i need the trumpet and the internal bracket i guess. cheers
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: rob.043 on 24 June 2011, 13:56
got a trumpet for a digi 8v box, if it'll fit its yours.

That would be awesome mate, apart from your in scotland... can you find out how much postage would be, i need the trumpet and the internal bracket i guess. cheers

PM'd
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: mk2bal on 24 June 2011, 19:57
I know a 16v with trumpet removed and a few added holes doesn't drone, if you have head under the bonnet on tick over you can hear a humm from it, but other than that when you give it some it sounds great. So much so the tunes get turned down...
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: beechymonza on 24 June 2011, 20:33
I gotta 16v, Whats this Trumpet bit ya all on about
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: andynorfolk on 24 June 2011, 20:51
I gotta 16v, Whats this Trumpet bit ya all on about

if you open up the airbox it has a trumpet inside it that the air travels in through, you'll know what we all mean if you open it up and remove the filter
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: beechymonza on 24 June 2011, 20:53
I gotta get around 2 changin my Filter 2 be honest, 4got all about it, Its only been in there 12 years now  :angry:
Title: Re: which panel filter?
Post by: redgolfgti16v on 24 June 2011, 21:07
i need a new air box as mine was butchered when i got it and the muppet actually drilled holes in the top of the airbox as well as the bottom :S

so im gonna upgrade the filter too... i have used pipercross panel filters in the past and have always been good, anyone else got any suggestions? i've always though k&n was just a name to sell cheap rubbish under...
[GOLF ./quote]DID A TEST FOR A MAG ON A ROLLING ROAD WITH 6 LEADING AIR FILTTERS RAM AIR CAME OUT BEST THAT WAS ON A 16V MK2.