GolfGTIforum.co.uk

Model specific boards => Golf mk6 => Topic started by: richellis1974 on 04 February 2010, 17:02

Title: mk6 GTI or MK5 R32???????????
Post by: richellis1974 on 04 February 2010, 17:02
I simply cannot decide........please help!!!!!! i LOVE the MK6 GTI but feel its a tad overpriced at the mo......Yet i have always loved the R32.....I know its thirsty....and expensive to tax, but that V6 and 4wd has to be a price worth paying????? It wont be a daily distance driver....just a short commute and FUN at weekends.........what would you do????? And REALISTICALLY what mpg is obtainable from a reasonably driven R32?????? I KNOW this is a GTI forum but i HAVE to know..... :shocked: :shocked:
Title: Re: mk6 GTI or MK5 R32???????????
Post by: Neil gti on 04 February 2010, 17:16
I simply cannot decide........please help!!!!!! i LOVE the MK6 GTI but feel its a tad overpriced at the mo......Yet i have always loved the R32.....I know its thirsty....and expensive to tax, but that V6 and 4wd has to be a price worth paying????? It wont be a daily distance driver....just a short commute and FUN at weekends.........what would you do????? And REALISTICALLY what mpg is obtainable from a reasonably driven R32?????? I KNOW this is a GTI forum but i HAVE to know..... :shocked: :shocked:

i use to average 18-20 mpg off my Mk5 R32 great car, great noise and now at a good price aswell,

my advice get one for a couple of years, (shouldnt lose too much money on it), sell it private and get a Gti when the prices have dropped :smug: :smug:
Title: Re: mk6 GTI or MK5 R32???????????
Post by: Freakinsweet on 04 February 2010, 21:56
I had the MK5 R32 before the new GTI came along. What I miss most is the exhaust note and the 4wd. I used to average 27.5mpg on my daily commute which is 50km turn-return trip. On longer trips (urban) 33mpg. Great car, great fun but I would still pick the new GTI any day. Refined interior, slick looks, good mpg etc. etc.
Title: Re: mk6 GTI or MK5 R32???????????
Post by: keelaw on 04 February 2010, 22:02

I agree the Mk6 GTI is the better car to live with due to better interior, nicer looks, etc.  however if I were in the market now, I couldn't hack the 6mth wait for a new car.  Personally I reckon you're better off with a nice well specced R32 with sat nav and leather and well over 5k saved in your back pocket!!


Title: Re: mk6 GTI or MK5 R32???????????
Post by: topher on 04 February 2010, 22:12
I recently sold my MK5 R32. Awesome all-round car but if i'm perfectly honest you could get something more fun as a weekend toy. Not that it isn't a capable motor but you have to drive like a complete plank to get anywhere near the limits of the car and is very comfy as a long distance tourer. Autobahn machine. Maybe take a look at 2.0 turbo scirocco.. or lotus exige if you're brave enough :evil:
Title: Re: mk6 GTI or MK5 R32???????????
Post by: DonnieDarko on 04 February 2010, 23:03
r32 every day of the week :D
and save up for a MkVII R in a few years time
Title: Re: mk6 GTI or MK5 R32???????????
Post by: Snoopy on 05 February 2010, 10:35

I agree the Mk6 GTI is the better car to live with due to better interior, nicer looks, etc.  however if I were in the market now, I couldn't hack the 6mth wait for a new car.   Personally I reckon you're better off with a nice well specced R32 with sat nav and leather and well over 5k saved in your back pocket!!

What he said no question. I would not go through this again.
Title: Re: mk6 GTI or MK5 R32???????????
Post by: MDSS MK6 on 05 February 2010, 15:59
r32 every day of the week :D
and save up for a MkVII R in a few years time

+1
this could become a movement :smiley:
Title: Re: mk6 GTI or MK5 R32???????????
Post by: wan888 on 05 February 2010, 17:13
Golf 6 just because of the interior ... and cars are always better being newer ... and did you check out that rear camera from the VW badge ... that's just too cool.
Title: Re: mk6 GTI or MK5 R32???????????
Post by: Snoopy on 05 February 2010, 18:12
Golf 6 just because of the interior ... and cars are always better being newer ... and did you check out that rear camera from the VW badge ... that's just too cool.
I would disagree with this myself. The last of the line models are often best as they have ironed out all the design and production faults by then.
Title: Re: mk6 GTI or MK5 R32???????????
Post by: Saint Steve on 06 February 2010, 18:59
and did you check out that rear camera from the VW badge ... that's just too cool.
That retro fits to a mk 5 for under £300  :wink:
Title: Re: mk6 GTI or MK5 R32???????????
Post by: Snoopy on 06 February 2010, 19:50
and did you check out that rear camera from the VW badge ... that's just too cool.
That retro fits to a mk 5 for under £300  :wink:
Do you have a break down of the parts cost?

I saved a copy of the DIY fitment guide.
http://cameluk.co.cc/camera.htm
Title: Re: mk6 GTI or MK5 R32???????????
Post by: JellyCat on 07 February 2010, 16:13
We needed to swap out the current 3 door for a 5 door for the other half (but for me to use when I want to put a big smile on my face and feel like an 19 year old again lol).

2 key reasons why I went got the mk6 gti - first was the new interior and toys like the rear camera, and second we couldn't get one with the right spec I wanted, so got a new one so could taylor the spec to how we wanted.
But... a 6 months wait again? Nah wouldn't have bothered if I could have got either a mk5 or a mk6 with a the right spec as I hate waiting, and the hassle of putting up with the 3 door while waiting.

Also that rear camera in the golf does seem to be the same as wha's in the Lexus IS if you've got the satnav option'd car.